News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How things get done by ChuckMcM on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @04:59PM (#6060181)
I can say from experience that as you get older and develop a broader understanding of the world, two things conspire against your focus; old ideas presented as new ideas, and scars of things not done.

In the first case you will find you are presented with some "new idea" which is so revolutionary it has its own set of buzzwords, its own methodology, and its own unique values. Except that it isn't new, its like those folks who drag up popular HN posts from 2 or 3 or 4 years ago and re-post them for the quick karma hit. There is are people who re-wrap old ideas and pass them off like holiday presents at a white elephant gift exchange. The trick there is to spend enough focus points to validate that the idea isn't really all that new, identify where (and if) it varies from what you've already seen/heard/done and then either discard or integrate it into the same slot.

The second is tougher. There was a really funny skit on Saturday Night Live where two psychics meet for their first date. As psychics they foresee all of the events from first date to heady romance to angry bittering to rejection and separation. They decide not to go out. As an experienced entrepreneur it can be really disheartening to be asked to walk down a road you've been down one or more times before where you know there is a pit of pain at the end of it. And then not proceed knowing the probable outcome without risking the possible better outcome. For example, try to find anyone, who did any startup in the 90's. to do a startup where you are selling pet food over the Internet.

Because of these effects I think experience can really have a damaging effect on focus if you don't actively work to avoid it.

Re:How things get done by swombat on Thursday July 18, 2013 @02:32AM (#6062117)
In the first case you will find you are presented with some "new idea" which is so revolutionary it has its own set of buzzwords, its own methodology, and its own unique values. Except that it isn't new, its like those folks who drag up popular HN posts from 2 or 3 or 4 years ago and re-post them for the quick karma hit. There is are people who re-wrap old ideas and pass them off like holiday presents at a white elephant gift exchange. The trick there is to spend enough focus points to validate that the idea isn't really all that new, identify where (and if) it varies from what you've already seen/heard/done and then either discard or integrate it into the same slot.

I'd strongly argue that this is a very bad filter. Almost all good ideas are "not new". The fact that you recognise them as not new just means you've been around the block now. 3-4 years ago they were just as old - you were just younger and more naive.

Discarding an idea just because it's not new seems foolish. If it's good, use it - even if it was first dreamt up by the ancient Sumerians.

Re:How things get done by ChuckMcM on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:54PM (#6065281)
I'm a big fan of going back and re-asking the question, this is because things change and sometimes stuff that was impossible before isn't now.

As an example, one of the things that 'killed' Java[1] in '94 was that the team had built this very easy to use 'cartoon' type UI for video on demand applications. The problem? Our "set top" box was a SparcStation 10 with two CPUs and 64MB of memory and a cg6 frame buffer. That configuration cost $15,000 (roughly) and we talked to cable type folks who were providing the set top boxes (OpenTV) and plant operators (Palo Alto Cable Co-op) and they agreed they were going to use more expensive set top boxes, they would spend perhaps $100 on one.

Running a complex, animated, graphical UI died that day.

But if you came to me today and said "We're going to have this really cool animation with a guy who runs around and makes suggestions and interacts with this world." I'd be totally cool with it because you can get enough CPU and graphics horsepower to do that for a retail price of $100 now.

So re-examining old problems again with new information is a worthwhile thing to do. And that is what older engineers need to be prepared to do (and if done well they can quickly zero in on the chances since they already know what went wrong the first time). And sometimes the problems with the first version still exist in this new shiny version, and in those situations, when you're not in a position to say "Please don't do this, it won't work." It is very hard to stay focussed on getting through enough of the steps so that everyone else understands as well.

[1] - One of the pitches the Oak (nee Java) team made to management about why the group should continue, was that it could help in Sun's battle with SGI and their efforts to dominate the interactive video market. But given the set top box requirement it was considered impractical. The server stuff lived on in "Sun Interactive" but the set top business was another dead end.

Re:How things get done by mkr-hn on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:44AM (#6062911)
This is how we get things like Reddit, HN, Digg, and N4G, even when we already had Slashdot. Trying to do old things better is a good way to go.
Re:How things get done by wslh on Thursday July 18, 2013 @10:01AM (#6063648)
Yes, think in tablets and how many "history cycles" required. The context of the idea is extremely important.

The lesson? If you have a rough idea about how the future will be in some domain start to build today. The difficult part of this is knowing what to build. For example, you need a fancy rich UI for your application but there are no components for that so you start building your own GUI library BUT at the same time juggernauts like Adobe, Sun, Microsoft, and Google try (in different technology eras) to move forward with Flash, Java, Win32, Silverlight, WPF, and HTML5.

What is the correct decision? Waiting like a Confucian can be the best option.

Re:How things get done by aytekin on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:49AM (#6062929)
Youtube was a bad idea in the 90s, but it became a good idea in 2005. Not knowing about old bad ideas can be a blessing.

Many startups succeed because they are ignorant of the fact that what they are trying is impossible.

Re:How things get done by nakedrobot2 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @09:33AM (#6063480)
The world was not ready for youtube in the 1990's. So whoever tried it then was "wrong" (also called "before your time" - but just because you're a visionary doesn't mean you're right - if your timing is wrong, you are wrong)

If I build a company that leverages everyone's mobile gigabit internet connectivity in 2013, I will not succeed, I will fail, because I am wrong. If I build this in 5 or 10 years, well, maybe the world will be ready.