Re:RSS mistakes: let's not make them again
by jessaustin on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:16PM
(#6058866)
If one doesn't like how her browser handles certain links, it's easy enough to get an extension or bookmark for that browser that does exactly what she wants. This is especially true for feeds.
Do you really think people who don't know what their browser is will install an extension or a bookmarklet?... Again, compare that experience to a click on "follow me on twitter" button.
Re:RSS mistakes: let's not make them again
by mpweiher on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:37AM
(#6061952)
I don't have to install any extensions in my browser. It Just Works™.
Re:RSS mistakes: let's not make them again
by sentenza on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:29PM
(#6058942)
What browsers actually hide the rss icon?
I too sometimes have to resort to the tactics that the article describes to get a feed, but it is usually just wordpress sites where the author is unaware that rss even exists or that rss is provided by wordpress.
I believe both Chrome and Firefox used to show an RSS icon next to the URL but both killed the feature.
Here's a Chrome plugin to add it back: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/rss-subscription-e...
Re:RSS mistakes: let's not make them again
by sentenza on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:42PM
(#6059021)
Ah, thank you. I am using Firefox for so long now that I can't remember when I started and somehow never noticed that the icon was there at some point.
Firefox's was actually pretty good in that you could click it and it made an attempt to format the feed for display and offered you links to subscribe to it using popular Feed Readers.
Chrome, even when it had the icon, by default linked it to the unformatted XML page. I get the sense that Google's heart was never really in RSS.
Re:RSS mistakes: let's not make them again
by Spittie on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @02:37PM
(#6059374)
Firefox still show that page, you just have to open the feed directly in the browser (instead of pressing that orange icon).
You can put the icon back in the toolbar, or you can press on the globe/keylock near the url, press on more informations, and then Firefox will show all the available feeds for the page under the "feeds" tab.
You can put the RSS icon back in the toolbar (but not the url bar) by going into View->Toolbars->Customize and dragging it wherever you want it. It's a bit less obvious than the original, but it's still useful.
Good luck with getting anyone who isn't a nerd to do it!
Yep. I offered the info in case it was useful, but I don't think it lets Mozilla off the hook at all. It's slightly better than completely getting rid of the feed detection code, I guess. That's probably the next step...
Yes, feedly is a browser extension, that you knew how to install Most people don't and most readers are not browser extensions...
I don't actually use the feedly browser extension, it mucks my pages up. I use normal web page feed links, and Firefox (the first time) will ask where you want to direct that rss feed, and if you have feedly open in a tab it proposes feedly as an option, and you can set it as the default so links always go to feedly. No extension required.
On sites that provide a feed link, I just click that link, which opens that feed in feedly, and I hit add to my feedly. Process is as simple as twitter. The choice of some sites to hide their feeds and provide no links is the burden of site designers.