Re:Reminding Starbucks that Beautiful Code Should Make Beaut...
by jaibot on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @12:43PM
(#6058658)
Singular "they" is a real thing. People who get upset about it are the worst.
Re:Reminding Starbucks that Beautiful Code Should Make Beaut...
by ndnichols on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:06PM
(#6058794)
I'm with you 100%. John McWhorter wrote a nice piece on it recently for TNR: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/112896/tyranny-pronouns-f...
Re:Reminding Starbucks that Beautiful Code Should Make Beaut...
by lubujackson on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @01:11PM
(#6058826)
Luckily, grammar rule don't evolve from what grammaticians want but from what people use. And a singular "they" sounds natural and follows the trend of language streamlining where it is most heavily used (there's a trend of irregular verbs becoming regular verbs based on usage).
The OP suggests guessing gender from names. There are too many unusual cases and gender-neutral names to be able to guess gender from a name alone. Even ignoring non-english-speaking world, I know several guys named "Kelly" and "Kim" and I have a female cousin named "James" (she goes by "Jill", though).
Adding a gender field is often not feasible and a bad idea for other reasons (gender identity, etc). It's far better to sidestep the issue with commonly-used-but-not-quite-formally-correct grammar, i.m.o.