News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by absconditus on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:26AM (#605509)
If you do not support a person's right to express an opinion that you abhor you do not support free speech at all.

While I disagree with their decision to prohibit photographs of nipples, doing so is unfortunately quite prudent lest US politicians decide to meddle.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by byrneseyeview on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:30AM (#605519)
There is a difference between supporting free speech and supporting it on a particular platform. The First Amendment doesn't give me the right to force the NYT to say what I want. Similarly, it doesn't require FB to post stuff it disagrees with; they're completely within their rights to censor this stuff.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by pookleblinky on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:37AM (#605533)
"censor"

A private citizen or company may choose not to broadcast whatever it likes, for whatever reason. This is not "censorship" except in the broadest and most meaningless possible sense.

I agree with you, but to call it "censorship" is to cede part of the argument.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by philwelch on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @01:59PM (#605853)
There's an important difference you're glossing over. If I post a photgraph to Facebook and Facebook takes it down, that's censorship. If I don't post the photograph in the first place, that's not censorship. That doesn't mean it's a violation of free speech or the first amendment, but we shouldn't redefine words like "censorship" just to gloss over all these issues.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by arebop on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:50AM (#605573)
Is FB more like the NYT or the ATT telephone network? I think it's a stretch to claim that FB is "saying" the things that users post on walls. Perhaps a better offline metaphor would be a mall tossing out someone for wearing an objectionable t-shirt or handing out pamphlets.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by absconditus on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:50AM (#605574)
I did not mean to imply that private censorship is forbidden by the first amendment. Freedom of speech is more than a legal right. It is an ideal that many of us support in all contexts.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by byrneseyeview on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:56AM (#605585)
You're supporting it in the sense that "Someone who wants to broadcast a message in a particular medium has the right to decide how that medium is used." Plenty of bad examples -- Pepsi doesn't have the right to push their products in Coke's newsletter.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by okeumeni on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:59AM (#605594)
After the Jewish haters, Facebook will have to deal with the Black haters, the neo Nazis, the anti abortion, the anti gays, the anti government, the fascists, the socialists, the chicken haters, the fast food advocates ...

The list is endless, you can just run around and shut down all non straight opinion makers and by the way Facebook is not NYT.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by swombat on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:51AM (#605575)
If you do not support a person's right to express an opinion that you abhor you do not support free speech at all.

I support their right to express it. I also support Facebook's right to remove them from the virtual, private premises for expressing it. I also support their right to complain that Facebook deleted their account because they were expressing hate-speech. I also support our collective right to side with Facebook on this one.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by thenduks on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @01:49PM (#605826)
I also support Facebook's right to remove them from the virtual, private premises for expressing it.

And Facebook has decided that it will not remove them. Issue closed. They've made their position pretty clear.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by absconditus on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:22PM (#605648)
Do you also agree that Google has the same rights to censor their search results in a similar manner? Would you agree with a decision to suppress results which lead to "hate speech" websites?
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by swombat on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:31PM (#605663)
There are some significant differences between Facebook and Google. We're not talking about hosting or removing pointers to information, we're talking about hosting discussion.

I would fully support Google's right to remove any discussion they don't like from any forums where they host discussion. I think making something disappear from the search results would be a little more delicate, particularly since Google are currently in a quasi-monopoly situation, but I would, on the whole, support their right to block search results that they want to block, yes.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by absconditus on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:59AM (#605595)
I support Facebook's right to censor them as well. I would not agree with their decision to do so, but it is their decision to make.

I write this not because I agree with Holocaust deniers. What if the issue were a 9/11 conspiracy theorist group? A group that discusses differences in intelligence between ethnic groups?

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by swombat on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:01PM (#605600)
What if the issue were a 9/11 conspiracy theorist group?

Then I would not support their removal. I don't have any credible evidence that 9/11 truthers are rooting for mass murder on a global scale, so I believe they're harmless.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by absconditus on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:10PM (#605612)
I realized that this wasn't a good example after reading your comment a second time. I added an additional example moments later.

Facebook is free to shape their community in any manner they see fit. If their goal is simply to have the largest audience possible then perhaps being overly political correct serves their purposes well. I happen to believe that a community is much more interesting when distasteful views are not censored. I'd much rather give users the option to suppress groups that they do not wish to see.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:32AM (#605521)
You do not have the right to express any random 'opinion'. Slander is always defended as 'an opinion' and both juries and judges rightfully punish those guilty of slander.

Holocaust denial is not 'an opinion': it is a blatant lie. There is no reason why spreading lies about historical facts should be less punishable then spreading lies about a companies' products. They both do damage and the cumulative damage of the first category is much more dangerous.

The first amendment is not there to allow idiots, fearmongers, demagogues and pussies to hide behind a twisted interpretation of the word 'opinion'. Neither uninformed statements that are false nor lies are opinions and neither is protected by the first amendment.

We forgive those that utter uninformed statements, 'for they know not what they do'. When they are informed of what they do and insist on repeating the statement, it becomes a lie.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by philwelch on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:14PM (#605623)
By your reasoning, it should be illegal to deny that the moon landing ever happened, or to deny that Lee Harvey Oswald was the assassin of JFK, or even to deny that human beings are the product of biological evolution. It's not the role of government, or of Facebook, to officially designate one version of past events as "true" and prohibit all consideration of any contrary version.

The Holocaust happened. It is sufficient to fully show the evidence of what happened and leave it at that. Prohibiting anyone from making claims to the contrary is no defense of the truth. Only liars need that defense.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:29PM (#605655)
By your reasoning, it should be illegal to deny that the moon landing ever happened, or to deny that Lee Harvey Oswald was the assassin of JFK, or even to deny that human beings are the product of biological evolution.

The first two don't need to be illegal, because they don't do much damage. There is little emotional attachment, making the controversy less influential or dangerous.

The last one is trickier: the education of children is certainly impaired by withholding facts from them. Everyone is entitled to every conviction, but no one is entitled to spreading lies about contrary convictions, not even to their own children. If we could reasonably make that illegal, I'd go for it, but I don't think we could write up a law in such a way that it would work. Those are the trade-offs that have to be considered.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by philwelch on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @02:17PM (#605896)
"The first two don't need to be illegal, because they don't do much damage. There is little emotional attachment, making the controversy less influential or dangerous."

Well that's rather ad hoc of you. If holocaust denial causes "harm" by convincing people that the Jews are liars, wouldn't Oswald denial cause harm by convincing people the American government covered up a coup it instituted against its own president, shattering all social stability?

Wouldn't moon-landing denial do the same thing? I seem to remember Buzz Aldrin getting real angry and punching a moon-landing denier in the face for calling him a liar. Do you think Buzz had a legal case for defamation there? Wouldn't moon-landing-denial hurt sales of Buzz Aldrin's books?

Why can't you just accept the fact that we have to share the world with a bunch of cranks?

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @03:46PM (#606063)
You are right that there is harm done in all cases, but the amount of harm differs and even breaking the law comes in degrees (at the discretion of the cop or judge).

I'm not arguing in favor of actually making this behaviour illegal, as it is simply not possible to formulate a proper law covering the exact behaviour you'd want to prevent. Any attempted law would be extremely prone to abuse.

I merely wanted to argue in favor of Facebook banning what they judge to be unwanted examples of holocaust denial, without fearing the wrath of people waving the 1st amendment around. What's good for facebook isn't necessarily good for a country :).

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by philwelch on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @07:56PM (#606288)
And if Facebook was banning them for being cranks, that would be one thing. I usually downvote crank comments on Hacker News because we're a specialized community that values rational thought.

To me, singling out Holocaust denial as the one prohibited form of crankism on Facebook smacks of exceptionalism. You can have conspiracy theories or contrary opinions about any other historical event, no matter how many people were killed—just not that one.

Notably, you can become a "fan" of Ataturk or Genghis Khan or Andrew Jackson or Christopher Columbus on Facebook, but not Hitler.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by tptacek on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @01:18PM (#605764)
So you'd allow conspiracy theorists, but outlaw Catholicism.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @02:29PM (#605919)
Catholics don't lie, do they? >:)
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by tptacek on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @02:31PM (#605923)
Catholics do many of the same things that human beings do. They're quite similar species.
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by randallsquared on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:48AM (#605565)
We forgive those that utter uninformed statements, 'for they know not what they do'. When they are informed of what they do and insist on repeating the statement, it becomes a lie.

The phrase "when they are informed" skips the step where they are somehow convinced of the truth of the information. Do you think that they "really know" the Holocaust happened and are actually lying, or do you think they're actually mistaken? If there's any significant chance of the latter (and if you think that Holocaust deniers are a serious problem, which I don't necessarily agree with), then figuring out what evidence would be convincing is important.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:16PM (#605630)
Of course they are convinced they are telling the truth, but that is not an acceptable excuse. If you go down that road, you can't put anyone in prison anymore: "they were just born and raised that way". A holocaust denier, or General Relativity denier for what that matters, arrives at his conviction through contingent factors that are nigh impossible to trace. Fortunately, that also isn't required. As in the case of the criminal, we still hold them accountable for their convictions and the damage that those convictions do, irrespective of their capacity to understand why it is wrong.

We like to believe that punishment teaches and that even criminals consider their punishments fair. Fact is: they don't consider them fair and they don't learn. Yet we keep punishing them, because locking them away makes life much nicer for the rest of us.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by randallsquared on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @01:34PM (#605803)
We like to believe

I think you're making broad assumptions about what we (by which I assume you mean world (or maybe just Western) civilization) want and believe which may not hold up to scrutiny. While they're often conflated, there are at least three different goals for what societies do to criminals: retribution, restitution, and punishment. Some of us think that it would be better to use the first two only, and that feeling "punished" should be only an effect of that. But that's another topic.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by Confusion on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @02:47PM (#605947)
I certainly grant that when I write 'we like to believe X, but', it means 'I would like to believe X and I think most people (like to) believe X'. :) Don't most people do that, perhaps without realizing it?
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by randallsquared on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @03:24PM (#606028)
I do think most people do that. I just think that here it's not actually the case (though maybe it is with the crowd here on HN; I'm probably more conservative than most here).
Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by mercurio on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @11:57AM (#605590)
The issue really is weakening of free speech rather than holocaust denial. Distorting facts should never be a justification to suppress speech. This is exactly the justification the Catholic church used for a long time, and they even have a word for it: heresy. Free speech really is our only tool to get out of situations where a bad idea or 'fact' is widely accepted and supported by those in power.

The irony here is that if Germans hadn't lost their freedom of expression under the Nazis, the holocaust might not have happened at the scale it did.

Re:Facebook Remains Stubbornly Proud Of Position On Holocaus... by uhtyrgh on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @12:46PM (#605693)
>Holocaust denial is not 'an opinion': it is a blatant lie. > There is no reason why spreading lies about historical >facts should be less punishable then spreading lies about >a companies' products. Creationism is a lie, a flat earth is a lie, that the world was created in 7days by a guy with a white beard is a lie. Fancy banning religions on face book?