Re:Show HN: Introducing Q.js, a library for modern web apps
by ricardobeat on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:29PM
(#6054536)
Releasing useful tools/libs as open-source is always a good thing, so congratulations and thank you.
However, I believe monolithic libraries are on the way out. Having small, composable libraries is a much better model: well-defined boundaries, easier to test, understand, maintain and contribute to. The shared knowledge that results can also lead to more stable/standardized APIs.
From a quick look, this library covers the same surface as jquery, backbone, underscore, a cookie-handling lib, async, a caching middleware, crypto, and more, added together. Adopting it for a project is a huge commitment, and means that every little piece of it has to fit your project well, or pieces of your project will have to be hammered to conform. I imagine it would spark more interest if it was broken down into smaller libraries.
However, I believe monolithic libraries are on the way out. Having small, composable libraries is a much better model: well-defined boundaries, easier to test, understand, maintain and contribute to. The shared knowledge that results can also lead to more stable/standardized APIs.
From a quick look, this library covers the same surface as jquery, backbone, underscore, a cookie-handling lib, async, a caching middleware, crypto, and more, added together. Adopting it for a project is a huge commitment, and means that every little piece of it has to fit your project well, or pieces of your project will have to be hammered to conform. I imagine it would spark more interest if it was broken down into smaller libraries.