News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Logic Pro X by scrumper on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:51PM (#6054309)
Your comment is a bit like free jazz: it's all very impressive on the surface, but it doesn't really mean anything and ultimately one feels like it was just an exercise in ego massage.

Logic has long had a home in the 'pro' world at the songwriting and demo production stage. You'll be hard-pressed to find an engineer in a commercial studio doing tracking or mixing in anything other than Pro Tools (though they certainly exist), but Logic has a healthy following with artists themselves. When viewed through that lens, the changes made in this version are a pretty natural progression for the software: for the most part, they're aimed at the writing and tracking process.

With that in mind, the 'Drummer' feature is less 'Garageband-y' than it might look: it's a considerably more flexible alternative to the giant pool of pre-recorded beats (Apple Loops) that Logic has had for a long time. Such a tool is pretty useful to the songwriter putting a demo together, to the music-for-picture composer, to the ever-growing army of artists who ship off near-completed songs to musician-for-hire studios on the web. I'm sure I'm not the only one who's heard those loops in commercial recordings (often in TV music, which is composed under deadlines to tighter budgets). I'm looking forward to being able to have my temporary backing rhythm follow the sections of a song: far better than trying to find a matching loop or building a beat from scratch when all you want is to lay down a guitar part and focus on developing your idea.

Your argument about the bypass button is just silly. If you have a bunch of plugins open on screen at once, it's obviously better to be able to see, at a glance, which ones are on or off. The old way made that harder. Clearly you have never sat for half an hour tweaking a compressor, certain of the improvement it was making, only to realize the damn thing was in bypass the entire time.

I can see more Pro-oriented things in there than you: a redesigned channel strip that reorients itself according to signal flow. Meters that work. A scriptable MIDI processor. Flex pitch, or whatever they called it. I also see a crisper UI and a clever way to facilitate interaction with complex instruments and plugins (the Smart Control macro thingies).

Of course, I'm just an amateur, so I suppose my opinion doesn't count. I suspect that you are too, but perhaps I'm just more comfortable with it.

-----

EDIT: I guess my long-winded point is this: why does it matter whether you think the program is becoming 'easier to use' (the horror); all that should matter is whether the new features are meaningful to you, and whether it breaks anything you need at present.

I work in enterprise software by day, and our UX team is constantly looking to consumer software and devices for usability ideas. There is absolutely nothing inherently bad about making something difficult become easy to use. It cuts down on errors, makes people happier, decreases stress, and makes them more productive. All of these things are just as valuable in the studio as they are in the accounts receivable office. There is nothing 'pro' about making life difficult for yourself.

Re:Logic Pro X by mrbrowning on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:14PM (#6054780)
I think the comment you're replying to rests on the assumption that it's not possible to optimize your interface for all levels of competency, i.e., changes that make an interface more beginner-friendly will necessarily limit the scope of possibilities available to power users or just make those possibilities more difficult to achieve. Not everyone agrees, of course, but it's not an unreasonable position. That said, although the Drummer feature looks a little bit silly, I agree with you in that I'm not seeing anything in this overview that indicates that the core functionality is being re-oriented in favor of beginner-friendliness.

(On a side note, the dig against free jazz seems unnecessary. It rarely makes sense to dismiss an entire genre of music as meaningless. Occam's Razor is a heuristic, not a law, but consider which of these hypotheses seems like the more reasonable choice to explain the datum "I don't hear anything meaningful in free jazz":

1. I am not concerned with or attuned to the musical priorities and structures that inform free jazz.

2. Everyone who derives meaning from free jazz, a group that includes some very skilled musicians, is wrong about it being meaningful.

The choice seems evident.)

Re:Logic Pro X by mambodog on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @09:35PM (#6055696)
As one of the other replies to your comment touched on, I am of the belief that it is very difficult to optimise a complex interface for all skill levels (while maintaining the same level of productivity for users at the high end).

You seem to be taking the term 'amateur' as dismissive or even insulting. I absolutely do not mean any offence by it, simply that it represents a shifting of focus of the application to a different group of users with a different set of needs. However, I see this group as already being served by something such as Garageband (perhaps with just a few additions of functionality).

I lament a truly great tool for high end users becoming watered down and less efficient for its established base, who know what they're doing and just need the interface to get out of the way as much as possible.

Regardless, I was attempting to express my genuine sadness and disappointment in one of my favourite tools becoming a bit less useful to users such as myself, I certainly didn't intend it to come across as an 'ego massage'.

Re:Logic Pro X by scrumper on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:12AM (#6057729)
I would encourage you to spend a bit of time with the new user manual for LPX. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised by what they've done: there's really nothing missing, concealed, or watered down; even the environment is still there. There are just some new ways to access that power.

Arguing about this stuff is all fun, but ultimately we're all musicians (among other things). Snarkiness doesn't help anyone, so I apologize if I caused any offense to you personally. I do stand by what I said about your comment though.

Re:Logic Pro X by scep12 on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @04:38PM (#6054590)
Couldn't agree more - there are far more pro-oriented features in this release than the few flashy garageband-y one demoed with the marketing material of the release. I haven't had a chance to dive in yet, but as someone who works in Logic day-to-day (albeit part-time), i'm ecstatic about many of the upgrades they've detailed on http://www.apple.com/logic-pro/in-depth/.
Re:Logic Pro X by scrumper on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:25PM (#6054844)
I'm time-pressed in a very different way to you: I get just a few hours a week in when my family is asleep and my chores are complete. That's why I'm excited about this new stuff: it looks like it will increase the percentage of my limited studio time I can spend actually playing and singing.

The thing I'm most looking forward to? The iPad app. TouchOSC is great, but this looks like I'll be able to load new instruments and create new tracks! Perfect: I can sit on my big comfy chair far from my screen, guitar in my hands, ipad on the arm, and muck about like I used to with a Portastudio. I might even break my iron-clad "No Apple dot-zero version" rule.

Re:Logic Pro X by initself on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @11:02PM (#6055895)
If you want a Portastudio feel with Logic, ditch the iPad and use a Frontier AlphaTrack: http://www.frontierdesign.com/Products/AlphaTrack
Re:Logic Pro X by rhizome on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @10:18PM (#6055793)
Your comment is a bit like free jazz: it's all very impressive on the surface, but it doesn't really mean anything and ultimately one feels like it was just an exercise in ego massage.

all that should matter is whether the new features are meaningful to you, and whether it breaks anything you need at present.

It's all too rare that a person's conclusion directly contradicts their own thesis.

Re:Logic Pro X by coldtea on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @02:35AM (#6056403)
I don't see any contradiction.

Checking if the new features matter to you, and your workflow is not "ego massage".

It's simply being honest about your needs and pragmatic.

The "ego massage" which the parent complaints about is a different thing, namely the: "I'm so pro, but Apple made it easier for amateurs, not 1337 like me, this sucks" kind of drivel.

Notice there was nothing about how it hampers HIS workflow, only high level, zero-content, judgements about it being easier for amateurs, the Drummer feature being toy like, the Garageband-pro meme, etc.

Not to mention that from the whole comment, one can easily deduce he hasn't even tried the software in person.

Re:Logic Pro X by rhizome on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @03:56AM (#6056621)
The contradiction is in promoting personal "meaning" (I'm guessing he actually means preference, though) in the composition of software features in an application, yet not allowing for the same to be a feature in the composition and practice of free jazz, a style he baldy denigrates as "meaningless." The only way this contradiction can be resolved positively for free jazz is if the style included pandering to his taste.
Re:Logic Pro X by scrumper on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:47AM (#6057612)
Well no, not really. My comment wasn't about free jazz, nor was it about meaning. I simply used a stereotype about free jazz as a tool with which to beat up the original comment.

Your interpretation is yours, and your choice to make a linkage between two usages of the word 'meaning' that weren't intended is also valid. I can't very well attack the original comment based on my reading of it and then ask you not to do the same to mine. That being said, my comment was structured like this:

1. Attention grabber: you're full of hot air. 2. This is why. 3. Here's a more mature way to think about pros, amateurs, and software.

I don't believe that the passing reference to a style of music has any real effect on the thrust of my argument.

I am slightly regretting picking on free jazz: its fans are, predictably, articulate. Perhaps I should have used Markov chain poetry instead of free jazz, then only the algorithms would be upset.

Re:Logic Pro X by cseelus on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @08:41PM (#6055565)
These kind of insightful/thougful comments are one of the reasons I (still) love hackernews.
Re:Logic Pro X by coldtea on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @02:28AM (#6056386)
>You'll be hard-pressed to find an engineer in a commercial studio doing tracking or mixing in anything other than Pro Tools (though they certainly exist)

In the US, maybe. In Europe Cubase and Logic are very prominent in studios.

And even in the US studios, Logic is used a lot alonside Pro Tools, for it's MIDI editing.