News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Logic Pro X by minikites on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @01:08PM (#6053159)
I wonder if it would have the same issues as the "open source" collaborative cookie:

http://log.scifihifi.com/post/344372246/it-may-have-been-a-f...

>[Y]ou’ll probably recognize the "Dream Team" of expert bakers convened by Gundrum as his "open source" group falling into the same sorts of traps (a lack of coherent vision, a reluctance to discount any idea, an obsession with novel and exotic techniques, a mounting frustration as individual contributors struggle to be heard). In the end, they turn in a passable but uninspiring product, while the traditional R&D team wins the competition by acting on a bit of clever insight from its leader.

Re:Logic Pro X by wavesounds on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:20PM (#6054139)
That's a really interesting point. IIRC in the Cathedral and The Bazaar[1] the author points out that a big part of the reason Linux was so successful is because Linus was such a master at running the project. Perhaps thats what these cookies were missing and perhaps an open source album would also need a 'Conductor' picking and choosing the best pull requests otherwise I could definitely see it resulting in lowest-common denominator blandness.

1. http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/homesteading/cathedral-baza...