News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by lucumo on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @06:55AM (#605172)
> What does this have to do with advertising? Since when is advertsing equated with speech? The type of advertising blocked by Adblock is a form of unsolicited communication.

You solicited it with your visit to the site. You didn't leave when confronted with the choice of using my site and viewing ads or leaving. If you don't like my ads, by all means: LEAVE.

Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by enneff on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @07:27PM (#606263)
Actually, I made an HTTP request to the main page, and then selectively loaded the rest of the page. How can you possibly argue that it's somehow my moral responsibility to load a web page in it's entirety? It's a patently ridiculous notion, and if your business model cannot support people that do it you're fucked.
Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by lucumo on Wednesday May 13, 2009 @06:06AM (#606690)
> Actually, I made an HTTP request to the main page, and then selectively loaded the rest of the page. How can you possibly argue that it's somehow my moral responsibility to load a web page in it's entirety?

You're not doing this by hand. The selectively loading argument is patently absurd. You're altering the standard behaviour of your web browser with the strict intention of denying a site owner their revenue source. You're using something without paying for it.

> and if your business model cannot support people that do it you're fucked.

This is not about my business model. My business model can support it fine, partly because there's so few people like you.

No, this is about morally corrupt people that need a lesson in civility.

Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by sho on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @07:35AM (#605213)
You solicited my visit by putting your website on the internet and leading me there by some means. Now I'm going to view it on my own terms. If you don't like that, block me, or take down your site.
Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by lucumo on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @08:11AM (#605237)
Sure. And if I'd opened a store and invited customers in, I was also inviting shop lifters. You know, because I solicited them by opening a store and leading them in by some means, so now they should use the store on their own terms.

I invited genuine customers of course, not leeches.

Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by axod on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @07:53AM (#605224)
I'll block you thanks. Don't be surprised if your browsing experience starts to suck as more sites follow suit.

Just like if I own a bookstore and you come in every day and read books and never buy anything. Pretty soon I'll ban you.

Re:An approach to fair ad blocking by enneff on Tuesday May 12, 2009 @07:24PM (#606258)
Why so smug? You should know there's no way to possibly prevent people blocking your ads.