News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Double Secret Surveillance by AnthonyMouse on Monday July 15, 2013 @10:59PM (#6049806)
>So instead of banning surveillance, which would be futile, it'll be much more practical to call for transparency, so the power generated by surveillance data is not concentrated to the select few.

Transparency is necessary but not sufficient.

Being able to see the government taking bad risks doesn't cut it if we can't actually stop them. And the problem is that it's not just the government and it's not just our government. You can't just come up with some restrictions on the FBI or the NSA (good luck with that anyway, and good luck enforcing it) while you ignore what China or large corporations might be doing.

Part of the answer to surveillance technology has to be anti-surveillance technology.

And I think one of the big things we need to push for is: We need more bandwidth. We need a national push for gigabit fiber to the home.

Copious transmission capacity attacks vulnerability to surveillance in two ways:

The first is that it reduces the practicality of storing all the data, by increasing the volume of data by an order of magnitude or more. We can price the spies out of the market.

The second is that it facilitates anti-surveillance technology. Tor is slow because it's bandwidth starved. Most people have piss-poor uplinks which are a factor of ten or more slower than their downlinks, which becomes the bottleneck if those users were to operate a relay. We need to solve the bandwidth shortage to make widespread use of that sort of technology practical.

Re:Double Secret Surveillance by andrewflnr on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:59PM (#6049948)
Yes. Don't give up, math is on our side. AFAICT, this is still true if quantum computing takes off. If surveillance is a technological problem, let's solve it. I think it's just a matter of time. People already want more bandwidth for more mundane reasons, and there's enough people who want user-friendly crypto that someone is going to get it right eventually.
Re:Double Secret Surveillance by dllthomas on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @09:44AM (#6051776)
The math is on our side in the case of encryption. Not all surveillance is meaningfully countered by encryption.