For better or worse it dramatically increased intelligence sharing and cooperation, as well as effectively tearing down the walls between domestic and foreign intelligence work.
I think that's the real issue, is that functional requirements cropped up with no point of focus, but when they instituted a new agency to handle that they wrapped it up with a whole Department and a grab-bag of other tangentially-related agencies.
That's actually one of the things I'm struggling with in my current job. I oversee a collection of units that can easily track a certain pool of wastefully-utilized resources, but have no actual power to fix it.
Those with actual directive authority over the individual elements of that pool have no incentive to correct things other than some guy 8 levels higher in the chain of command being irritated.
And a third party that actually does the work that would get elements of this pool out of the pool drag their feet on it completely as for them it's "just admin".
So I get to make reports on this waste everyday but with little effective power to fix it. Standing up an audit team that would have the power to fix requires resources, resources which no one seems to have now...
I don't know your situation well, but perhaps it may be time to look around.
But, even if I felt like it, what happens when I leave and the next guy comes along who doesn't care at all? The situation I'm talking about here isn't one of my primary duties, it merely happens to be related. Right now this issue is essentially no one's primary duty, which is one of the problems.
My proposed solution is a tested principle from software refactoring, applied to organizations writ large. In fact I've often been surprised at how well software engineering practices can translate over to organizational systems design practices.
I've noticed similar in software practices (especially project management and metrics) leading broader org design. I'm not sure if it's because the failures are bigger, or the orgs are more willing to experiment, but software firms do seem to drive HR and organizational design trends.
And here we are, almost 15 years later and nothing has changed or improved. Several commentators even argued if the DHS actually worked, several of the recent terror attacks would have been prevented.
Either fix it, or get rid of it.