News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reinventing the School by arethuza on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:23PM (#6047527)
A quick question - when you say "where every kid could branch off to follow their interests" does this imply that kids in the US education system don't choose a set of subjects to focus on at about 14?
Re:Reinventing the School by SirSkidmore on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:37PM (#6047639)
Completely true, if not implied. I just graduated from secondary school in the US. I want to be a programmer, but I never once took a programming class; my school didn't offer them. Most of my peers still have NO idea what they would like to study, even though some of them are paying $10,000-$20,000 to go to college.

At least at my school (a small rural secondary school), there just weren't enough classes to to "specialize" or focus on any one particular field. You just took the core classes every year: a science (sometimes), a math, an English.

Re:Reinventing the School by dragonwriter on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:45PM (#6047695)
> I just graduated from primary school in the US. I want to be a programmer, but I never once took a programming class.

Normally I would say "that's okay, you've got plenty of time to do that in secondary school (middle/high school)". But then you go on to say this:

> Most of my peers still have NO idea what they would like to study, even though some of them are paying $10,000-$20,000 to go to college.

If you just graduated from primary school, why are your peers going to college? That's quite odd. I suspect, in declining order of likelihood, that either "primary school", or "college", or "peers" is an error...

Re:Reinventing the School by zanny on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:58PM (#6047781)
US doesn't see middle / high as "secondary" school. Secondary school is college. Primary school is just the K-12 process because it is continuous with no breaks in between, besides maybe the divide between one year being led around hallways by a teacher and next going room to room on your own.
Re:Reinventing the School by dragonwriter on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:06PM (#6047838)
> US doesn't see middle / high as "secondary" school.

Yes, it does. [1]

> Secondary school is college.

No, secondary school is either equivalent to "high school" or equivalent to "middle and high school". [2] College is "post-secondary school". [3]

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_school#United_States

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_school#United_States

[3] e.g., http://www.cpec.ca.gov/SecondPages/CommissionHistory.asp

Re:Reinventing the School by SirSkidmore on Monday July 15, 2013 @02:58PM (#6047782)
yeah, sorry, fixed. It's a Monday, can you tell?
Re:Reinventing the School by Kuiper on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:39PM (#6048060)
I attended a California high school in the 00's and most of the courses I took were prescribed; each year we got to take one "elective" course. Some students use these elective courses to take additional levels of courses that they are required. (For example, students are required to take one year of chemistry; some students such as myself opted to take a second year of chemistry. However, these students were a very small minority; I believe that only around 20 students of a graduating class of 1000 students opted to take more than one year of chemistry in high school. There were also only two tiers of each science course, meaning that you couldn't take a third year of a given science.) I lived in a county with a large Hispanic population (whites were a minority), so Spanish classes were offered and were a popular option for an elective course, with many students opting to spend multiple years in Spanish classes. Some of the elective courses were tied to non-athletic extra-curriculars, like band, orchestra, choir, and the speech & debate team. Other electives included various visual arts, creative writing, "agriculture" (learn how to maintain a garden, "computer skills" (learn how to use Word and Excel), welding, drafting, and cooking, as well as the yearbook committee.
Re:Reinventing the School by arethuza on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:57PM (#6048173)
Interesting, here in Scotland at year 3 of Secondary School (~14 years old) you choose 8 subjects from about ~40 available (this varies on the school). You have to take English, Maths a Science and a Social Science - but you have a reasonably choice. These are examined at age 15 in "Standard Grades".

In 5th year (~16 years old) you usually do 5 subjects - not sure if any of these are compulsory (English used to be, but I don't think it is now) - these are examined in your "Highers" (Higher Grades). I did Maths, Chemistry, Physics, English and Engineering Drawing (this was before CS was available, it is now).

Highers are used for University entrance and, in Scotland, depending on your birthday you can get your Highers and be off to University when you are 17. Sixth year at secondary school in Scotland is either used top up your exams if you didn't get enough to do the course you want, doing more advanced courses and/or going to parties...

The downside of this approach is that you specialise very early - basically you choose at 14. Which is great if you know what you want to do and not so good if you don't. This is aggravated by UK Universities traditionally having very focused courses e.g. I did a CS course and all we had was 4 years of Computer Science and Maths classes with some Statistics for light relief. Again this is great if you pick the right course and dreadful if you make a mistake.

[NB I have a 14 year old son and we've just been through the trauma of picking Standard Grade courses]

FYI Here is a exam paper for an Advanced Higher in Computing, which I think is pretty good:

http://www.sqa.org.uk/pastpapers/papers/papers/2012/AH_Compu...

Re:Reinventing the School by zanny on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:02PM (#6047810)
No, they don't. K-12 is strictly adherence to state standards education with very little room for "optional" coursework, and even where they is the option, the staggering monotony and disdain a student would have for the primary subjects they spend 80% of their time in they will have no energy or effort left to be truly passionate about a choice subject (usually).

IE, my 8-12th grades had strict guidelines : must finish algebra, must have a course in each of the 4 primary sciences, must have world and us history and government, must have literature classes covering 4 time blocks from early writing -> Renaissance writing -> new world writing -> modern writing.

Must have gym, must have a foreign language (after 6 years of Spanish, and 2 years out of college, I can't remember a word of it since I never used it). I think I got one class per year I could "pick", and the closest to software / IT was web design which was just how to make a wordpress site, and never touched html / css / js.