Re:A new way to write mathematics
by Tichy on Monday July 15, 2013 @04:16AM
(#6044291)
I really disagree. A proof is a proof, doesn't matter if it helps you understand anything or not.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That can't be right. Otherwise you might as well just churn out billions of proofs like "Proof that 34634+7684=42318". Surely the only value in a proof is whether or not it helps you understand something?
The value of a proof is a different matter.
And for example knowing e=mc^2 might be valuable in itself, independent of understanding relativity theory.
I don't know what you mean. e=mc^2 requires at least some understanding to make any use of it, lest you suppose burning a single lump of coal will keep your power station running all week ;-)
And even then, you need to know that "e" stands for "energy"...
It wasn't the best example, but let's take the area of a circle, which is r^2*PI. I don't even know the proof for that by heart, but I can still make use of the information.
A proof simply tells me that something is true. Further understanding is just a bonus.
The understanding here is that πr^2 is the area of a circle.
You are saying that this understanding is important/useful even without the proof.
This is in direct contradiction to what you said earlier, where you said the proof was important/useful even without the understanding.
Perhaps we're using the word "understanding" to mean two different things here and that's where the contradiction lies.