News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new way to write mathematics by zepolud on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:26AM (#6044184)
This is extremely shallow. This guy deliberately focuses on the most tabloid-style reporting of the HoTT book he could find, a New Scientist piece, and then uses it to attack the book itself for having unsubstantiated grandiose claims. Well, guess what -- you're reading a New Scientist article, what did you expect?

Perhaps it would be more befitting to a person in his position (a CS professor, it appears) to actually critique the book itself. Judging by his rant, it's doubtful he even read it. Otherwise he would have known that the most controversial thing about it is a preference of constructive proof, when possible, as they are generally both more illuminating and rely on fewer assumptions.

Re:A new way to write mathematics by tome on Monday July 15, 2013 @04:26AM (#6044324)
Is he really attacking the book, though?

"I feel compelled to say something about not his work, but the New Scientist article. The article is at best in my opinion misleading."

Re:A new way to write mathematics by foobarbazqux on Monday July 15, 2013 @03:45AM (#6044221)
More broadly it seems that he's oblivious to the field of automated theorem proving altogether. Why would people devote their lives to ATP if it weren't useful? Of course humans need to derive insight from proofs, but it's also important for them not to have mistakes.