Also in this case the wrongs make up the vast majority of viewed content. Live video is much harder to police from a content owner's perspective and they know it. The lawyers gotta be out documenting shit during an event. Look what they require to take something down:
http://www.justin.tv/user/dmca
All that for stuff that a ten year old could tell is stolen. I have no respect for startups that base themselves on theft.
I guess you're hoping that if you repeat this often enough we'll forget that copyright infringement isn't theft? Sadly, that will work on a fair percentage of folk, which is why I feel it's important to reply with something like this at least some of the time.
Can you be more precise? What are they doing that's different?
Let me make it clearer for you. How are JTV's copyright policies any different from those of other UGC sites?
What's intellectually dishonest is to pretend there's such a thing as an "average" UGC site. The others vary enormously in the amount of copyrighted stuff they have on them.
Looks like an Everybody Else Is Doing It argument. What makes "the same copyright policy as any other UGC site" morally acceptable? It's easy to read that as "we'll make money from your content until you catch us".
In other words, they do exactly the same thing as every other UGC startup, in every other medium.