News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by ewzimm on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:10PM (#6041400)
Can we please stop repeating the provably wrong statement that Firefox is too slow to use? Tom's Hardware has recently shown Firefox beating the performance of both Chrome and Opera. No benchmark is absolute, but you can just use it and see for yourself. Also, it still has better extensions.

Source: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/chrome-27-firefox-21-ope...

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by crazygringo on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:51PM (#6041751)
Can we please stop repeating the misleading statement that Firefox is fast enough, because of benchmarks?

When people talk about Firefox being slow, they're not talking about page rendering speeds or JavaScript execution times. They're talking about the longer delays in switching between tabs, in closing tabs, opening a bunch of tabs at once and still having the interface be responsive, and so on. User interface stuff.

Unfortunately, I don't know of any user-interface-responsiveness-speed benchmarks, so it's basically impossible to "prove". But that doesn't mean that people who complain about Firefox being slow are imagining it. The only reason I use Chrome instead of FF on my machine is precisely because the UI is an order of magnitude faster in mundane things -- instantaneous rather than pausing a bit on every little thing.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by effn on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:05PM (#6041805)
My experience is the opposite. I find Chrome horribly, horribly slow to use. Safari is ultrafast and FF somewhere in between.

I still use it because I've become so accustomed to its UI but I switch to Safari on some sites to avoid spinning up the fan.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Watabou on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:02PM (#6042027)
My experience has also been the same.

Chrome on the mac is absolutely dog slow to use, especially after you open up a few tabs. Seriously, why do people say it's fast? I really don't get it. It was fast at one point but now it feels slow, bloated and the tabs crash far more often than either Firefox or Safari. If I only had a penny for every time I see the sad face on tab crashes.

Firefox has no lag whatsoever when switching tabs, and general usage. Maybe people think it's slow because of its dated UI? Maybe they haven't used it at all? Maybe they're still using Firefox 10 or older? Firefox 22 is awesome. People just need to give it an unbiased try.

Safari is the fastest of them all, both in rendering speed and general usage, though it tends to use a LOT of memory.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by saraid216 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6042332)
I honestly wish I could use Firefox as my development environment. I prefer Firebug to the Chrome dev tools. But I've been slowly forced to admit that it can't keep up. With Chrome, I can casually open up a dozen tabs without considering the consequences; in Firefox, I get worried when I have two open. This pans out in the Activity Monitor.

There exist huge inconsistencies in all of these claims, and it's extremely strange how difficult it is to work out what third variables are involved that are causing such vastly different reports.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:52PM (#6046771)
I have heard reports of considerable performance improvement from users clicking on "Firefox Reset" button. Have you tried it? You can find it in about:support (or somewhere in the Help menu, I can't remember where).
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by straight_talk on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:28PM (#6042324)
Chrome is very fast on my 4.8Ghz Windows PC with literally hundreds of tabs open sometimes. Almost as fast as Waterfox. If it slows with a few tabs my guess would be the OS is swapping Chrome processes memory to the swap file (or files). FWIW I just put 32GiB in my machines and remove all swap files.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:51PM (#6046759)
Yes, Chrome is very sensitive to swapping, performance-wise.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by bulatb on Sunday July 14, 2013 @06:33PM (#6042511)
Mine is opposite your opposite. :) On my 2.5GB, 1.8GHz Core Duo Thinkpad from 2006, Chrome handles dozens of tabs in multiple windows like a champ. Firefox pre-24 was noticeably slow with just a few tabs in a single window. It's been unusable for me since 2011.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:28PM (#6046582)
In Firefox, have you tried "Reset Firefox", in about:support? Most users report that this speeds up Firefox considerably.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by bulatb on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @02:09AM (#6050261)
Thanks, I'll give it a try.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by cbhl on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:13PM (#6042269)
I find that this kind of behaviour is symptomatic of a machine which has a slow hard drive. Have you run benchmarks on your disk? What kind are you using? (SSD? Magnetic 3.5"? 2.5"?)
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by makomk on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:48PM (#6042183)
I find that Chrome generally switches tabs instantly, then takes an age to actually display the contents if I have a significant number of tabs open.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by alipang on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:13PM (#6041405)
Benchmarks are not everything. Firefox feels sluggish and less responsibe when scrolling, switching between tabs, on startup and just in general.

This might not be the case one every machine, I don't know, but it's been consistently true for my usage, it just doesn't feel right.

Unlike the new Opera I might add, it provides a really great experience. The fact that you can now install chrome plugins did it for me as I was a vimium addict. I think the move to blink was the right move for them.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:05PM (#6042040)
I believe that there are two things being discussed here. One is performance. The other is reactivity.

Performance (aka throughput) measures the total duration of operations, e.g. how long does it take to display a page once it is loaded, how fast a script will be executed, etc. When Chrome was introduced, its performance was much greater than Firefox, largely due to v8. Some other factors involved were add-ons (it used to be really easy to write Firefox add-ons that kill performance, and it used to be impossible in Chrome), or old bloated profiles (which of course didn't exist in Chrome). Now, after lots of hard work, the Mozilla community has managed to make Firefox faster than Chrome. That's what is measured by benchmarks, and that's one point for Firefox. Simultaneously (and this doesn't appear in benchmarks) the Chrome add-on and profile situation have started to show the same weaknesses as Firefox'.

Reactivity (aka snappiness) measures how fast an application appears to be, i.e. the total duration of user-visible pauses, e.g. how long does it take to switch between tabs, or how much one tab eating all CPU affects other tabs. When Chrome was introduced, its reactivity was also much greater than Firefox, largely due to the multi-process architecture. Some other factors involved were add-ons, once again, or old bloated profile, or simply the fact that the Mozilla culture initially didn't take into account this factor. It took some time for the Mozilla community to realize that reactivity was just as important as speed. After lots of hard work, the Mozilla community has managed to make Firefox... well, much better than it used to be. Improvements include off main thread rendering, off main thread disk I/O, asynchronous add-ons, etc. Unfortunately, desktop Firefox does not have multi-process architecture yet. This gives a considerable advantage to Chrome in this domain.

Work is ongoing to bring this multi-process architecture to Firefox desktop. The task is long and difficult and might, unfortunately, kill a number add-ons, but I am confident that the Mozilla community will achieve it.

Incidentally, FirefoxOS has a multi-process architecture already.

Caveat: I'm a Mozillian, and I'm involved in Reactivity work in Firefox.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by gojomo on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:16PM (#6042281)
Perhaps the "long and difficult" multi-process architecture will be the ultimate fix, but it'd be great in the meantime to get some tiny hint about which tabs are sucking up memory/cycles. This could be very crude - a count of the tab's timeout-firings, object allocations or whatever - and it would still allow significant self-help.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @06:24AM (#6044689)
For memory, you can already look at about:memory. For performance, if you are running Nightly, you can use the Gecko profiler that basically tells you everything about what takes time. Note that, by design, the Gecko profiler is activated only on Nightly releases.

But yes, both features are rather hardcore. We are working on more user-friendly solutions, too, although I have no idea of the roadmap.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by straight_talk on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:31PM (#6042334)
>> Unfortunately, desktop Firefox does not have multi-process architecture yet.

I personally hate Chrome for creating a process per tab. It adds a little bit of security, but it makes harder to manage the processes in a system.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:50PM (#6046753)
For what it's worth, the multi-process architecture is designed to customize from one-process-for-all-tabs (plus one for the ui and one for Flash) to one-process-per-tab. I don't know whether this will be a released feature, though.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by pacomerh on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:38PM (#6041702)
I agree with this, FF might get great benchmark results, but the overall experience is what matters and I still think chrome feels snappier overall.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by zachlatta on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:48PM (#6041738)
While we're talking about what "feels snappier," why hasn't anyone mentioned Safari. It is, by far, the smoothest browser on my computer. It may not do as well as Chrome in the benchmarks, but the scrolling is a thousand times smoother and everything feels quicker.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by ewzimm on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:57PM (#6041767)
If the default scrolling isn't to your taste, you might want to try addons like this one for Firefox:

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/smoothwheel/?...

Of course, if you're happy with Safari, by all means stick with it.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by abrowne on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:16PM (#6041413)
Even worse is the second part of their sentence. They say, "Unfortunately, Firefox is too slow and far behind the Chrome." Far behind in what exactly?
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by givehimagun on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:37PM (#6041699)
The article is an op-ed piece...not a technology article.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by abrowne on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:40PM (#6041711)
Sure, but even so they could be more clear. The statement is so vague I don't know if I can even choose to agree or disagree with it!
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by pooriaazimi on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:59PM (#6041782)
I have the latest versions of Safari and Firefox, on the latest version of OS X. Safari has about 15 extensions, has been used daily for the past 5 years (and I haven't deleted its history, though I clear the cache one every couple of months). And I use Firefox "only" if I need to access the web-based GMail (which happens roughly every 2 months), and there are no extensions installed in Firefox.

Considering the above, Safari still is (much) faster than Firefox on my machine. I don't care if it can render JS 5% faster - the whole experience is sluggish and slow on my machine. Of course, YMMV.

Just wanted to point it out to you that there are legitimate reasons why people say Firefox is slow.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Sunday July 14, 2013 @03:32PM (#6041911)
Out of curiosity: have you tried "Reset Firefox" (in about:config – you won't lose anything if you don't have add-ons)? Most users experience a huge speedup when they use it.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by gojomo on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:09PM (#6042250)
I don't see a 'Reset Firefox' option when I visit 'about:config' (FF/23.0 'beta channel' MacOS).

(UPDATE:) Per <http://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/reset-firefox-easily-fix..., it appears 'about:support' is the right place. I suspect this would help, but the problem would recur as soon as I restore my core Add-ons and usual tabs.

In my experience, Firefox gets slower and slower the longer it's been open and with many tabs open. I believe it to be related to GC. Unfortunately, there aren't any hints (like per-tab activity/memory/allocation/timer readouts) as to which tabs are contributing the most to the problem. Sometimes I'll guess the miscreants and closing enough of them helps, but more often things only improve after a restart (essentially unloading all tabs until revisited).

It does seem add-ons are implicated (and perhaps especially Firebug, even if Firebug is not activated in any tab). NoScript may also be implicated; especially with regard to pages that have some but not all script sources enabled.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by pooriaazimi on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:20PM (#6042303)
It's in Help -> Troubleshooting

Read this article to see what it preserves (or "tries to preserve"): http://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/reset-firefox-easily-fix...

FWIW, I just tried it and it indeed made things a whole lot faster.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @06:25AM (#6044697)
Cool :) We are working on ways to make this a little more intuitive.
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by pooriaazimi on Sunday July 14, 2013 @05:14PM (#6042274)
It did indeed! Thanks!

BTW, I didn't find "Reset Firefox" in the about:config page - it was in Help -> Troubleshooting Information.

Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by Yoric on Monday July 15, 2013 @06:25AM (#6044692)
My bad: "about:support", not "about:config".
Re:Reasons to Choose Opera over Chrome by a3n on Sunday July 14, 2013 @01:33PM (#6041478)
Provably wrong depends on when the proof was done. Firefox releases occasionally go through performance low points, to the point that I can't stand it. I then switch to Chromium, until I can't stand the user experience anymore, then I switch back to Firefox which by then has usually been fixed. Until next time.