Of course it is desirable to give the attacker a chance to retreat by firing a warning shot. If he continues and you're in imminent physical danger, you shoot at the legs.
And only if that did not help you go for the torso.
(If there is enough time, if the killing shot is the only one you're ever going to get to fire, then that it is)
Extending his remarks, if you hit the femoral artery in someone's upper leg, they're going to quickly bleed out unless they get serious first aid.
I'm sorry to hear that the US have not developed some sensible framework of self-defense.
What do you not find sensible about Florida's? If you accept Zimmerman's account of the incident, which we presume the jury did, he only resorted to lethal force after he was in legitimate fear for his life, and he never had an opportunity to retreat (states vary greatly on duty to retreat vs. stand your ground).
What do German courts require?
German self-defense law is even stronger than all those Stand Your Ground laws in the US.
I guess only here law professors can write about the "ignominious/dishonorable flight" when discussing options against an attacker.
"Justice does not have to yield to injustice" is a very common saying.
But even if the law allows you to strike back, it's usually still a good idea to retreat. :-)
Indeed; the good thing about Stand Your Ground (SYG) laws is that they presume the citizen without fault will make a good decision on that and don't allow the state to second guess him along with everything else it will be questioning (i.e. SYG doesn't touch on biggest question of "is this use of lethal force justified?", which should be the real focus).
I've seen some horrible abuses of duty to retreat from your own home in Massachusetts when the courts were negating as much of every legislative reform as they could; you should never have to decide between abandoning your children to the tender mercies of a thug and going to jail (real case, followed contemporaneously in the Boston Globe in the early '80s).
"Generally it's preferable to discuss the limitations of self-defense with the prosecutor, than having the family discuss with the undertaker."
He had the option to not follow someone, and to stay inside his vehicle, as he was advised to do by the police he called.
Poking someone with a stick and then killing them when they respond is a bizarre use of self-defence.
Again by his account, while returning to his vehicle he was confronted by Martin, who said the first and also hostile words, and not even the prosecution claimed that Zimmerman initiated force, the affidavit strangely changes to the passive voice, "Zimmerman confronted Martin and a struggle ensued".
It comes down to who's use of lethal force was justified; I find it bizarre you don't think getting your face pounded, as confirmed by an eye witness, and getting your head bashed into concrete, also confirmed by photos and the physician's assistant who attended to him, isn't sufficiently lethal force to allow a reply of lethal force in legitimate self-defense.
That isn't even going into Zimmerman's claim that when Martin realized Z had a gun, he said he was going to kill him and reached for it.
Ask police officers or soldiers if they shoot at the legs of threats, or if their first shot is towards center-mass.
I also wonder if any state license(s) held by the shooter required learning that warning shots are unlawful. As a guy who doesn't own guns, it seems extremely counterintuitive.
Any reading or training you get on this subject will emphasize that you can only use lethal force when it is necessary to stop a threat of "grievous bodily harm" or the like including rape, or death, so by implication warning shots are not legitimate. (Texas is not surprisingly a special case, it uniquely allows the use of lethal force after a verbal warning to stop the theft of property, don't know how warning shots are treated by that state.)
As a non-gun owner this may strike you as extremely counterintuitive, but it's a general part of most any training you might get or relevant safety rules; you own every bullet you shoot, you're responsible for what they hit. E.g. see Jeff Cooper's 4 safety rules, which I consider to be the best set: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Cooper#Firearms_safety Note rule 4: "Identify your target, and what is behind it. Never shoot at anything that you have not positively identified." A shot into the floor is not 100% safe, you're directing a lot of energy into it, you don't know what that might kick up. However, she shot a wall, and that's inherently dangerous unless your nearest neighbor is far, far away which I gather wasn't the case (Jacksonville has 1,100 people per square mile).
None of this would appear to be relevant to the case, the court determined she was guilty of attempted murder vs. lessor charges that I assume could have applied, like assault. If they'd believed her dodgy claim of self-defense it shouldn't have resulted in a judgement that she was actually trying to kill her husband.