News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We need both engineers and artists in programming by swombat on Monday May 11, 2009 @09:05AM (#603391)
Fine, if all you want is software that works, i'm sure you can find some bored engineers to write software that just works.

Meanwhile, the rest of us will continue to have fun with software that does amazing stuff and sometimes breaks.

There's a not-so-old saying: "Brilliant people are often hard to work with, but if I've got to choose between working with a brilliant person that is hard to work with, or a stupid person that is easy to work with, I'll always choose the former."

The same is true of software. When you're pushing the envelope, things break. Learn to live with it, or stop bothering with computers until those of us who are more passionate about doing extraordinary things have left the field. We should be done in about 50 years.

Note: this is not a defense of cowboy programming. It's a defense of genius cowboy programming. If someone like Linus Torvalds, as an amateur student programmer, wants to write something as awesome as Linux, who are you to suggest that he shouldn't?

Re:We need both engineers and artists in programming by jleyank on Monday May 11, 2009 @09:14AM (#603411)
You're (aggressively?) missing the point. If you're doing research, pushing the envelop, then by all means have a go! If, however, you're writing stuff to sell, that people will depend on, then do it well. Calling somebody a professional != calling them an engineer. Slowhand's certainly a professional guitar player, and I think there's general agreement he's not an engineer...

When Linus did his groundbreaking work, that was pure creativity. Redhat, however, better be a little more grounded.

Re:We need both engineers and artists in programming by swombat on Monday May 11, 2009 @10:52AM (#603546)
So then we arrive at exactly the point that the article made: you need both.

You need the "artists", i.e. the extraordinary, unprofessional people who do something crazy that no professional would ever attempt, and come up with something that pushes the envelope in new and unexpected ways.

And you need the "engineers", the professionals who will convert that (or other things) into something steady, reliable, rock-solid.

I don't think that your rephrasing helped, personally. It made a point which was in agreement with the article look like it was a disagreement.