News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret government: America against democracy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 11, 2013 @07:35PM (#6029986)
> My question: why would the process that surveils foreigners

Right here is the fundamental problem. The lack of effective constraints in the FISA process (and we've already discussed, in this thread, why the domestic process targeting criminal action, despite superficial similarity, has stronger incentives for government restraint than the FISA process) is exactly why we cannot trust that it only surveils foreigners (it is intended to do that, but absent effective constraint there can be no confidence that it is used as intended.)

> I ask in part because I think synthesizing an adversary is unlikely to create a meaningful restraint; a synthetic adversary doesn't have the same incentives as a real one.

Sure, from the perspective of constraint, a synthetic adversary is worse than a real one, and selecting a synthetic adversary in a manner which makes it an effective constraint is tricky, but getting a real adversary into the foreign intelligence surveillance warrant process is, well, difficult to do without serious negative consequences.

There are no comments on this comment yet.