You'd have to also replicate the covered population and make sure that there's a "USA" outside paying for drug development and the like.
Past that, most of the competition is not in innovation, but rather in marketing.
"The researchers’ estimate is based on the systematic collection of data directly from the industry and doctors during 2004, which shows the U.S. pharmaceutical industry spent 24.4% of the sales dollar on promotion, versus 13.4% for research and development, as a percentage of US domestic sales of US$235.4 billion." -- http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/01/080105140107.ht...
Finally, the NIH is picking up most of the tab for fundamental research, and as such, it isn't the drug company that is leading innovation. As such, I find the drug development argument hollow.
Are you claiming that the existing statins address all relevant cases?
> which shows the U.S. pharmaceutical industry spent 24.4% of the sales dollar on promotion, versus 13.4% for research and development, as a percentage of US domestic sales of US$235.4 billion
That's a non sequitor.
> Finally, the NIH is picking up most of the tab for fundamental research
"fundamental research" isn't a significant fraction of the cost of drug development, aka "getting a drug into the pharmacy".
The problem with U.S. politics in general is that it is fractured. Policy is determined by the interplay of powerful, organized factions. Any government intervention gets captured by these factions, and the policy ends up hurting the general interest rather than making things better.
Here is a comment I made a while ago where I explain how American politics works in practice: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=557298
get over it.
a free market solution means dying baby gets turned away when parent has no money. otherwise it is not a market solution. no one wants this. no one. move to somalia, you can implement your plan there, life is cheap.
healthcare is not a business. no civil society is going to let you decline cusomters who cannot pay when it comes to keeping the baby alive.
Read more about Singapore's healthcare system here: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/01/singapores_heal.... http://www.american.com/archive/2008/may-june-magazine-conte...
But coming back to Earth, such a plan could never happen. If you approach the problem from the perspective of a hypothetical policy advisor, there is very little that is both a) politically possible and b) would actually improve the system. Raising the caps on medical school enrollment is an obvious fix that would reduce costs without costing taxpayers anything, but the doctors will try their hardest to block it. A mandate to buy insurance makes sense in theory, but in practice the required level of healthcare to buy gets set way, way, too high, and so a mandate ends up being a huge transfer from citizens to the healthcare industry. There are dozens of other examples. Our system is f*ed up for a reason, and until the political system is reformed, policy reform is impossible.
In reality, healthcare spending will continue to rise until it simply cannot rise further. The spending will be distributed according to political power.