News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by crazygringo on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:17PM (#6026997)
> but its pretty self-evident that the effect on actual prices is dependent on price elasticity of demand in the markets for particular products

Of course, but there's still the "minimum profitability" that a business seeks to have. Suppose three firms compete to sell widget X, and consumers are willing to pay up to $10 for it, but the companies sell it at $5 due to competition (it costs $4 to make and distribute). Then the price is determined by supply cost + reasonable profit, determined by competition. If the government removes part of that profit, they'll raise prices accordingly, and sell for $6 instead, since that's still within the demand price elasticity -- otherwise the firms would decide there wasn't enough profit and get out of the business entirely.

> No more than taxing labor income... is really taxing corporate stockholders

The difference is that taxing labor income can be intentionally progressive, which is widely believed to be a good thing.

> But taxing high salaries is "regressive"

That just doesn't make any sense -- words can't be redefined like that. The very definition of progressive taxation is taxing high salaries (EDIT: incomes) of individuals at a higher rate than lower ones.

I understand your overall argument -- it's certainly debatable to what extent you believe corporate taxes to affect prices, vs to what extent you believe personal income tax to affect market salaries. But that doesn't affect the point I was making, which is that corporate taxes are ultimately passed onto people, and that this is not done in a progressive way. But by taxing people directly instead, this can be done progressively.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by unclebucknasty on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:41PM (#6027173)
>"corporate taxes are ultimately passed onto people"

I don't really get this argument. It's always made as if the taxes are applied in a vacuum where market forces no longer exist.

If corporations are operating in a competitive market, they will seek cost advantages and continue to compete for market share. Raised taxes represent an additional expense (for the purposes of this discussion), much like raised energy prices. It is not always the case that these costs are passed on to consumers. Rather, smart companies seek to become more efficient, reduce costs elsewhere, or even realize a slightly lower profit margin per unit in order to maintain or increase market share vs. other competitors.

There's also the option to reduce executive compensation, decrease shareholder dividends, and a host of other options available in the interest of remaining competitive. A smart company could actually outmaneuver other competitors, wind up with more volume, realize the same net profit after taxes, and pass lower prices on to consumers.

I mean, there are just a ton of other variables here. And, those who advocate low or no corporate taxes are frequently free marketers. So, it's very interesting to me that they all but completely ignore very relevant free market mechanisms that can countervail the effects of raised corporate taxes.

IMO, it's just an oft-repeated meme that "higher corporate taxes are automatically regressive because they automatically create higher prices for consumers".

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by JonFish85 on Thursday July 11, 2013 @03:50PM (#6028692)
Isn't it an easy solution though? Based on what you've said, companies have likely already done what they can to reduce expenses to what they consider an optimal place.

I'll try an example, although that might not be totally valid (I'm not really up on current tax laws). These are all made-up numbers and rates: Say you sell a widget for $100, and it costs you $70 to make. Your profit on that is $30, of which let's say you pay $5 in taxes, so let's say you walk away with $25 per widget.

If the government bumps up the taxes by a percentage that makes the tax be $6. As a corporate policy, the easiest way to keep the same returns to investors is to tack on another dollar to the price and sell it for $101. Profit is $31, pay $6 in taxes, still walk away with $25/widget.

Your competitors are in the same boat as you are, regardless of what the tax rate was/is. Theoretically, if they weren't stealing your business at the lower tax rate, they won't steal it any more or less at the higher tax rate.

Sure maybe you consider some other areas to cut costs, but haven't you done that already? I know it's a silly over-simplified example, but if I own a company and I don't want to give back my profit, I raise my prices to compensate, and so do all competitors. The people that lose are the customers.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by unclebucknasty on Thursday July 11, 2013 @05:42PM (#6029424)
I see the rationale in that argument, but I think one of the things you're missing is that companies won't just automatically raise their prices in unison.

Smart companies may hold their prices constant and take a per unit profit hit to capture more share, allowing them to maintain or even increase overall profit. They may introduce higher margin products and/or develop entirely new strategies or lines of business.

And that is the free market mechanism that I mentioned: each company must adjust to the new reality and try to use it to gain an edge over its competitors. They do this all the time.

And, given this new incentive to maintain profits, they may be more aggresive in finding cost reduction elsewhere. One might argue that companies are doing all they can now, but you might be surprised at how new realities create new incentives.

The other important thing with returning shareholder value is how Wall Street works. It is very much a time-relative game. For example, how did the company do vs. last quarter or same quarter last fiscal year? Viewed this way, you can see why some companies pump the brakes on all out profit-maximization over a given timeframe, instead opting to ensure that the line keeps moving up and to the right over a longer period. So, it's more complicated than all companies are always maximizing profit at all times.

Finally, your example that the easiest thing to do is to raise the price by, say, $1 doesn't really hold, irrespective of what direct competitors do with their pricing. They must still keep prices in line with what the market will bear. If not, consumers may begin looking for substitutes or go without (depending on the product). So, while it might be the simplest thing for a company to try, it might not be accepted by the market.

This is all part of the free market at work. So, your simplification is tempting, but I think it goes back to creating that vacuum I mentioned, ignoring all of the many market variables that countervail the assumption that $1 in increased "cost" equals $1 in increased price.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by JonFish85 on Thursday July 11, 2013 @06:23PM (#6029661)
If the market has reached the pre-tax equilibrium, would an added evenly-applied tax change competitiveness at all? I guess I don't see how that would change anything at all. If you and I are competitors, and we both pay the same tax rate, that's already factored into our businesses in some way. Sliding it up or down an equal amount on both of us won't change the me vs. you competitiveness right?

I get what you're saying regarding only pricing what the market will bear, but on the flip side of all this, consumers suddenly have more money, so I could make the argument that the consumers are willing to pay more because they suddenly have more in their pockets, and around the mulberry bush we go...

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by unclebucknasty on Thursday July 11, 2013 @10:23PM (#6030539)
>would an added evenly-applied tax change competitiveness at all?

Any variable can change competitiveness, as companies may differ in their responses to it.

For example, look at fuel prices for airlines. When they increase across the board, some airlines may raise prices, others may cut back on services offered, still others may add baggage fees, some may focus on increasing volume on more profitable routes, some may lower prices and heavily promote their lower fares to gain market share, while others may risk prepaying for fuel at current prices or hedging with shorts, etc.

Point being, of course, that the same change that hits every competitor will produce different responses and effects. This can completely alter the competitive landscape. And, it's virtually a guarantee that you won't simply get some uniform, across the board price increase.

If we don't acknowledge this, then we are looking at the change in a vacuum, completely insulated from the realities of free market behavior.

>I could make the argument that the consumers are willing to pay more because they suddenly have more in their pockets

Yeah, I think I actually mentioned that in another post (too much risk/work to view another post mid-reply on this tablet). Anyway, it could definitely be the case that consumers can bear more, however, it is not neccesarily 1:1. That is, there are a lot of variables that might impact whether they'd be willing to spend that extra money on that product. Also, there is still some price that the market simply won't bear for a given product, irrespective of the extra money in consumer pockets. In any case, there is certainly no guarantee that companies can simply pass on the additional cost.

And, it can also be the case that some companies can, but others cannot, given their prior prices.

Just too many variables.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by lmartel on Thursday July 11, 2013 @05:42PM (#6029426)
What if no one buys your widget for $101? You'll bring the price back down to $100 very, very quickly.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by chatmasta on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:54PM (#6027288)
> reduce costs elsewhere

Like by hiring less employees.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by unclebucknasty on Thursday July 11, 2013 @01:05PM (#6027370)
Possibly. Unless the tax code gave them incentive to cut costs elsewhere instead. I would guess such incentive to be logical, given the problem they're trying to solve.

In any case, one of the big premises of the article is that hiring less is happening anyway and contributing to the need for a basic livable income. So, that's a bit circular.

And, of course, that's just one of many potential cost-cutting measures.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by flyinRyan on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:49PM (#6033607)
Good thing we've got BI then, so we're no longer slaves to making any move at all because it might cost someone a shit minimum wage job.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by rayiner on Thursday July 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#6027717)
> Raised taxes represent an additional expense (for the purposes of this discussion)

Raised income taxes aren't really an additional expense, because they are taken out of after-tax net income, not gross income. That complicates the analysis substantially.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by rndmize on Thursday July 11, 2013 @02:15PM (#6027934)
This is precisely the reason I don't understand it when people say the cost of the tax will be passed onto consumers. What cost? The tax is on profits...
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by talmand on Thursday July 11, 2013 @03:12PM (#6028438)
You may see it that way, but most businesses do indeed see tax liabilities as a cost of doing business. Just because the profits are taxed doesn't mean it's not a cost of some sort. For instance, you could say today's taxes are the cost of doing business next year or even quarter.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by rayiner on Thursday July 11, 2013 @04:17PM (#6028897)
But mathematically taxes don't behave like costs.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by talmand on Thursday July 11, 2013 @04:54PM (#6029170)
Depends on how the company applies the math. If a company wishes to treat tax liability as a cost of doing business, I fail to see how that couldn't be done.
Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by unclebucknasty on Thursday July 11, 2013 @06:01PM (#6029549)
I am aware of how the accounting works, technically, which is why I added the parentheses.

Perhaps you can provide more detail as to how you think it changes the analysis in the context of this discussion.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by a_c_s on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:39PM (#6027159)
But 'reasonable profit' isn't a constant. Just look at the airline industry - no single airline has had a consistent profit margin (most have not even been consistently profitable!). Thin margins aren't incentive to leave an industry - if they were then grocery stores would not exist (as they all have razor thin margins) and WalMart, Target, Kmart would all have switched industries.

In your example, if taxes of $0.50 are added, the firm may still sell widgets at the post-tax price of $5 and accept the reduction in margin from $1 to $0.50.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by dragonwriter on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:30PM (#6027096)
> That just doesn't make any sense -- words can't be redefined like that.

I used the quotes and the "just as much as..." reference because I was applying your logic about corporate taxes to the alternative you proposed. I don't agree that either is regressive, obviously, and I laid out exactly why that logic was wrong earlier in the post, before showing how if you ignored the fact that the logic was wrong and applied it consistently, it would say the same thing about your alternative as it said about the thing you proposed the alternative to.

> The very definition of progressive taxation is taxing high salaries of individuals at a higher rate than lower ones.

Actually, the usual definition is about taxing higher incomes at a higher rate. Confusing income with wages or salaries , so that one ignores non-labor (and, particularly, capital) income in considering the progressivity of taxes, is a pretty serious error.

Re:Trends that will create demand for an Unconditional Basic... by dllthomas on Thursday July 11, 2013 @12:50PM (#6027252)
But that "reasonable profit" is itself determined by the other opportunities available.