News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by adventured on Thursday July 11, 2013 @06:42AM (#6025324)
You're incorrect. I'd argue it depends on what you're prejudiced against, as to whether it's noble. I happen to be very prejudiced against police states, and government tyranny in general, and the people that actively help to make it possible. In this case, my use of Feds is meant to represent the federal authority figures that are leading the charge in erasing my civil liberties, and I think that was obvious given the rampant discussions here for weeks on the NSA and its leading proponents.

A proper synonym for prejudice is bias. I like that word even better than prejudice in this case. It can be said that I'm absolutely biased about this subject.

Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by dragontamer on Thursday July 11, 2013 @07:20AM (#6025407)
Lets start with a basic fact. A good portion of the NSA is dedicated to purely defensive cybersecurity. They have contributed to SELinux, created the DES encryption algorithm, as well as SHA-1 and SHA-2. NSA had a part in AES as well. They were also involved in figuring out what happened with regards to the Google and Nasdaq hacks.

Even if you believe the NSA's actions were wrong with regards to collection of metadata... a good portion of even the NSA's workforce have nothing to do with that current controversy.

Even then... if you manage to convince yourself to be a bigot towards ALL NSA employees, you'd have to be awfully bigoted to then further apply your judgement to the rest of the Federal Government workforce.

Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by throwaway2048 on Thursday July 11, 2013 @07:45AM (#6025476)
and the german government under Hitler built the autobahns and created Volkswagen.

At some point, any participation in a system that allows such broad and systematic abuses needs to be called out.

yes, i know about godwin's law, thanks.

Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by lclarkmichalek on Thursday July 11, 2013 @08:59AM (#6025735)
I can't say I harbor any great animosity towards road builders in Germany in the 1930s.
Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by dragontamer on Thursday July 11, 2013 @10:07AM (#6026068)
And ditto to us Americans as well. WWII was filled with errors, and yet our ideals have remained strong.

A brief history lesson: Office of Censorship, Atomic Bomb (historic Kyoto was on the list of places to utterly demolished... fortunately the Japanese surrendered before then), Napalm-based firebombings against a civilian population (Japan). Blatant racism in the form of the Japanese Internment camps, etc.

The existence of these programs are in direct contradiction to many principles that America stands for... especially the Office of Censorship. But we don't hold any ill-will towards our Grandfathers during that time. At worst, we recognize the specific faults in the specific laws in the context of the time period, and then write laws to ensure it never happens again.

Same thing will happen here. "Feds" in general were not related to this controversy. Showing ill-will to such a large group of people is straight up bigotry. We have the intelligence today to focus our energies on specific departments, specific people... specific regulations that have gone wrong in this case.

And that is what law is about. Figuring out the root of the problem and eradicating it. Painting entire groups of people (aka, "The Feds") with a single brush is wrong.

Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by pdpi on Thursday July 11, 2013 @06:53AM (#6025352)
Nope, still not noble. If it's truly prejudice, then just because you're prejudiced against a bad thing doesn't mean the prejudice itself is good.

But what I think is that you're trying to describe a rational, sensible dislike for tyranny and police states as prejudice, which is disingenuous at best.

Re:For first time ever, feds asked to sit out Defcon hacker ... by Jtsummers on Thursday July 11, 2013 @09:14AM (#6025804)
You understand that most federal employees were as unaware as the general public, right? Just being a federal employee doesn't grant omniscience about all the government's activities. Lumping them all together isn't like saying Google did this, or Microsoft did that. It's more like saying, the tech industry did this (when really it was 2 or 3 companies, and just departments or divisions within them). It's nonsensical. If you're a pacifist are you going to blame the entire aerospace industry for building military aircraft, even the companies that don't have military contracts? Are you going to blame all software companies because a few write DRM software?

We're entering into a baby-with-the-bathwater situation here. Straight up defense is considered, by most, to be good. The interstate system (as a whole, some regions and sections, not so much) enables a great deal of commerce. These fall under the purview of the federal government, should we toss them out as well? Or should we have a more measured and less emotionally induced (panic and fear and hate) response?