Being the most discerning doesn't make you a better person, it just makes you less happy more of the time. The recent X-Men: Origins film is a good point - look around the net at some reviews, there's an awful lot of criticism going on.
I enjoyed it, discerning people didn't. We're both out two hours and the cost of a ticket. Which is a better situation to be in?
Of course a lot of the motivation for being discerning, especially in regard to food and drink, is class aspiration. Money isn't enough. Urban and suburban Americans engage in a lot of competition to see who can live the most enlightened and refined lifestyle. It isn't the most productive way that energy could be channeled, but considering it's an expression of some of our basest, most ruthlessly hierarchical human tendencies, we could do a hell of a lot worse.
Eh? Surely it's more challenging to enjoy a mediocre film than a really enjoyable one? To create a good picture from a point and shoot camera than a $4k DSLR? To be happy with a $800 used car is more challenging than being happy with a $60k luxury car. Isn't it?
Discernment can offer some advantages, though. A movie can be bad in interesting ways, or simply interesting in spite of being bad. Plus, the more qualities you can appreciate about something, the more likely you are to find something redeeming about it.
Of course I probably give off that attitude sometimes...
As a student I used a cross pencil because they provided the most comfortable pencil(The cushion tip is a mandatory feature in my mechanical pencils). Now I switched to a cheaper draft/matic mechanical pencil that provides a superior writing experience at a more reasonable price point.