Re:Chrome 28 arrives with Blink, rich notifications for apps
by dherman on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:58PM
(#6023876)
Yes, threading is definitely the main challenge for asm.js. I'm not as pessimistic as you about it, though. :)
Re:Chrome 28 arrives with Blink, rich notifications for apps
by justinschuh on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @09:05PM
(#6023894)
To be clear, I really do think those of you working on asm.js have the best of intentions and really want to make something that works for the Web. However, I expect that supporting existing codebases and commonly used APIs is going to mean compromises. They'll start small and polyfills will work well enough, but I just don't see how asm.js doesn't eventually diverge in significant ways from normal JavaScript, or end up introducing special purpose hacks. Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't see my position as unrealistic.
And really, I'm far more concerned with the future plans, particularly with regard to things like multi-threading APIs. I don't see how those can be incorporated in a way that supports asm.js as an easy target for existing code while not causing it to diverge from JavaScript as used in the browser.