The agency model wasn't the illegal thing, it was just the one part of the mechanism of the used for the illegal price fixing conspiracy.
> It seems to me if an offense was committed, it was committed by publishers in renegotiating their Amazon contracts, in unison, towards the agency model.
The publishers were, indeed, charged with conspiring in the price fixing scheme. All of the charged publishers settled with the DoJ rather than going to trial. Apple wasn't singled out, it just seemed that way because they were the only defendant left when the trial started.
> How is Apple implicated?
Apple is implicated as a member of the publishers' horizontal price-fixing conspiracy who sought to advance, encourage, and profit from that conspiracy.
>This meant that the iBookstore would always have the e-book at the cheapest price. It also meant that if a retailer was offering the book for a cheaper price, the publisher would have to lower the retail price to match it. If that meant the price was below what it cost to produce, the publisher would take the loss, not Apple — they would still get their 30% cut.
>The traditional purpose of MFNs are used to protect a retailer’s ability to compete, ensuring that they aren’t disadvantaged by the wholesaler giving their competitors a better deal. The DOJ contends that the way this MFN works, it was designed to “protect Apple from having to compete on price at all, while still maintaining Apple’s 30 percent margin.” Those are strong words, but there is certainly a kernel of truth to that.
http://www.macstories.net/stories/understanding-the-agency-m...
It seems to me if an offense was committed, it was committed by publishers in renegotiating their Amazon contracts, in unison, towards the agency model. How is Apple implicated?