At the time of the agency switch it was obvious something fishy was going on with the whole Amazon v MacMillan "buy button" battle. The DoJ's investigation uncovered plenty of evidence about what that was: a conspiracy among publishers to force Amazon to the agency model. And all the publishers settled before getting to trial, which certainly supports the strength of the DoJ's evidence and case.
Now consider a publisher conspiracy. The DoJ's argument against Apple is that they were the enforcer that made the publisher conspiracy possible. You may agree or disagree with the judge about whether or not the evidence supports that argument, but it is a serious, carefully-thought-out line of logic either way.
No, the line of logic was that because there was specific evidence of them conspiring with the Publishers, it was (to the standard required in civil cases, which is far from "must be") apparent that there was a conspiracy.
> Amazon was, and is, the monopolist using classic monopolist tactics
Whether or not Amazon is a monopolist (or even illegaly leveraging a monopoly) might be relevant in an anti-trust trial of Amazon, but it really doesn't have any relevance to an alleged price-fixing conspiracy involving several of Amazon's suppliers and one of their competitors.
1. Being a monopoly isn't illegal. You don't say this, but using the word monopolist makes it seem like you think that such a thing alone is criminal enough.
2. Lock-In? What part is the lock in? The fact that I can buy a Kindle and never purchase anything from Amazon? The fact that the DRM used for ebooks from Amazon are optional and decided by the publisher?
3. Undercutting prices? So?
Amazon was, and is, the monopolist using classic monopolist tactics (lock-in, undercutting prices, etc.) to retain a monopoly. Of course once their monopoly was ensured they'd pivot to make a true profit if pesky Apple hadn't interfered: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/05/business/as-competition-wa...
I can't help but feel that this was driven by politics/optics (to your average person, of course lower prices is better).