I look at G+, and as it happens GMail, and I just see a confusing mess. I have to look at it for a second or two to sort of orientate my self, and let the site sort of focus. I'm sure its the flat design lark we are currently in the middle of. Last time I used facebook (I "deleted" my account a year or so ago) it was far clearer and instantly use-able. Although looking at it now, using one of my kid's profiles, its beginning to get as bad.
I might actually use G+ if it were use-able. I have joined two groups, purely because people migrated there from Usenet, and every time I want to check whats what in these groups I come away wishing I hadn't bothered. Good job the one I most care about is a slow burner.
So, for me the biggest barrier is the UI.
"There are other problems. Tagline? Bragging Rights? Skills? Links? Is G+ a page for socializing or a resume?"
I think they're aiming to be the social network for hobbyists, not the social network for dating or for employment or for spamming or whatever that other networks focus on.
There are other problems. Tagline? Bragging Rights? Skills? Links? Is G+ a page for socializing or a resume?
I simply cannot fathom why some people in the tech industry think that G+ is in any way a viable competitor to Facebook. Outside of the tech bubble, its usage is nonexistent and unhelpful. It is cluttered with things people don't want, and it lacks some of the basic things people DO want.