Re:“Weird Paranoia” at Valve, Says Former Employee
by xaritas on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @07:21PM
(#6016356)
I'm familiar in passing with Bakunin and Marx, so I'm not really surprised by anarchist tendencies in modern progressive movements. The passing down of mores, forms and customs among groups that tend to eschew tradition is interesting to contemplate. This particular thread of transmission (if it holds) has a satisfying symmetry to it. Especially if you, uh, enjoy historical ironies.
The origins of the hierarchy/nonhierarchy dispute on the left are a bit clearer, if that's what you're looking for. The polemics between Marx and Bakunin would be one place to start to see that side of it. To over-simplify, Bakunin thought that Marx's views had a dangerous authoritarian tinge that risked just replacing one kind of authoritarian government with a different one; while Marx thought Bakunin was an idealistic hippie out of touch with real-world situations, whose views would at best go nowhere, and at worst result in the workers' movement getting crushed as they spent all day holding disorganized meetings. For a later historical episode, something about the May '68 protests in France would probably have something informative. They were led by young leftists with non-hierarchical views, and opposed by the more orthodox French Communist Party. But I don't know as much as I'd like about that period, either, apart from the Situationists producing a lot of clever slogans.