Again you are missing the consequences. Acting indignant is not going to bring you more oil/gas/water/ice/food. Letting the prices go up will do it. No amount of moral indignation and Talmudic discourse on when its right to charge what is going to change what incentives people follow to actually deliver you the goods in times of disasters.
Is tripling the price on New Years Eve in NYC gouging? Not really - it's the same as prices going up for flowers around Mother's Day or Valentine's Day. Demand will be high and would likely not be met if prices remained the same.
Small bumps in price will probably be tolerated due to acts of God, but not outright gouging.