Many -- I'd say even most -- students base their careers on something besides projected income. I think this is a very good thing.
Yes, especially people with childhood dreams of studying history or art will be turned on by the prospect of designing airliners and nuclear reactors.
As always, the US drops the ball again.
Hence why it has to be a blanket tax. How many people would opt-in to social security if it wasn't mandatory?
There are a lot of students out there who don't go into college with the sort of super-high self-confidence that would cause them to turn down a free education because they think they'd be better off with a traditional loan. So the question is: will enough of them make enough money to make it a workable solution? My guess is yes.
That's more interest than the cost of the loan. You would have to average more than 203K a year in salary in order for this to be the wrong choice. The average student isn't going to come close to that. Do you really expect that you'll be making more than an average of 203K over the next 24 years?
With the direction higher education costs are moving, this could be a very inviting choice for those who would pay for college with student loans.
Then do you oppose the idea of public universities generally? Atlas Shrugged is a work of fantasy and light philosophy; I don't think it's relevant to the problem at hand.
If a university (or a state) chooses to force everyone to study under this model, they'll find that students expecting high-paying jobs will go elsewhere, and students expecting low-paying jobs will flock to those schools.
Fundamentally, if I'm planning to study CS for the next four years, it's a good bet that I'll be making more money than someone getting an English degree; and I don't particulalry want to subsidize their education with my future earnings.
There's a close parallel here with John Galt quitting his job in Atlas Shrugged.