News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by karamazov on Sunday July 07, 2013 @04:57PM (#6003443)
This has a critical flaw: those expecting to work in a high-paying field will self-select more traditional loans, whereas those pursuing a degree with less promising income expectations will disproportionately opt for this type of loan.

If a university (or a state) chooses to force everyone to study under this model, they'll find that students expecting high-paying jobs will go elsewhere, and students expecting low-paying jobs will flock to those schools.

Fundamentally, if I'm planning to study CS for the next four years, it's a good bet that I'll be making more money than someone getting an English degree; and I don't particulalry want to subsidize their education with my future earnings.

There's a close parallel here with John Galt quitting his job in Atlas Shrugged.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by icn2 on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:05PM (#6003468)
This is the part I am always confused. If we all know graduates getting an engineering degree(CS,EE) make more money than graduates with english/arts degree. We should see an obvious trend students heading to engineering majors. Why still so many students go to english/arts/... major and they know they will make less promising income?
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by jmduke on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:15PM (#6003512)
Why still so many students go to english/arts/... major and they know they will make less promising income?

Many -- I'd say even most -- students base their careers on something besides projected income. I think this is a very good thing.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by dantheman on Sunday July 07, 2013 @07:21PM (#6004046)
Unfortunately they're taking on massive amounts of debt that will make their life more difficult. If they could only receive a loan for a percentage of their projected income then they'd be able to decide if it's worth it. And it would put price pressures on the school.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by cdavid on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:42PM (#6003655)
Same could be said of doing a MBA or medicine compared to STEM. Yet few people on HN made that choice.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by icelancer on Sunday July 07, 2013 @06:51PM (#6003942)
Not even close RE: MBA. There is an insane glut of MBAs because of rational choice to go there where MBAs used to have a ton of opportunity. Then the economy crashed and now STEM fields are being mined for business intelligence / game theorists that can learn rudimentary business practices on the fly (or the company will pay for a night-time MBA).
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by wtvanhest on Monday July 08, 2013 @12:09AM (#6005139)
The majority of people who struggle with getting high paying work after an MBA previously struggled with getting high paying work as a Stem graduate. Something like 40% of MBAs are engineers.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by capulcu on Sunday July 07, 2013 @06:08PM (#6003765)
Not the same thing. Once you're in a US college, you can pick your major, whether that's English or STEM. But for Medicine or MBA, you need to be admitted to a postgraduate program. I remained a STEM because I didn't have the grades for medicine. Didn't "choose".
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by cdavid on Monday July 08, 2013 @08:30AM (#6006383)
that's a good point, shows my European bias. In France at least, entering in medicine or decent engineer career path requires similar level of grades. Entering into a MBA would be similar to get a very good engineer degree (grade-wise, skills being different obviously)
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by MJR on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:08PM (#6003479)
Isn't it obvious that it's because they aren't interested in a career in engineering? For some people having a higher income is not more important than having a career that they enjoy or that inspires them.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by sneak on Sunday July 07, 2013 @06:16PM (#6003796)
From my limited experience with the matter, it's because 18-year-olds are stupid.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by gngeal on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:33PM (#6003615)
We should see a obvious trend students heading to engineering majors.

Yes, especially people with childhood dreams of studying history or art will be turned on by the prospect of designing airliners and nuclear reactors.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:00PM (#6003451)
How is this any different than simply raising taxes and providing education at minimal cost with no loans?

As always, the US drops the ball again.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by dangrossman on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:29PM (#6003593)
It's an opt-in tax only on the people that receive the benefits of the program. I actually like that idea; it wouldn't work for everything, but I think it can work for higher education.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by toomuchtodo on Monday July 08, 2013 @11:09AM (#6007127)
So its like health insurance if you don't make it mandatory. Only the people who are going to maximize their utilization of it are going to opt-in.

Hence why it has to be a blanket tax. How many people would opt-in to social security if it wasn't mandatory?

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by bajsejohannes on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:29PM (#6003592)
Small evolutions are easier than big revolutions.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by enraged_camel on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:44PM (#6003662)
Evolutions take a long time. Can we as a nation really afford the luxury of waiting?
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by majormajor on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:51PM (#6003692)
Most of the people most likely to want to opt out are, I imagine, already effectively doing by not going to the Oregon state schools and going to, say, a highly ranked private university. Or they might be getting substantial scholarship assistance as it is (it's unclear to me how this would work under the new system, the article could use more details there).

There are a lot of students out there who don't go into college with the sort of super-high self-confidence that would cause them to turn down a free education because they think they'd be better off with a traditional loan. So the question is: will enough of them make enough money to make it a workable solution? My guess is yes.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by MJR on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:03PM (#6003463)
At a 100K salary, over 24 years you would pay 72K. The same cost of 72K as a loan at 6.8% paid over 24 years would amount to $146,229.96 with total interest paid of $74,229.96

That's more interest than the cost of the loan. You would have to average more than 203K a year in salary in order for this to be the wrong choice. The average student isn't going to come close to that. Do you really expect that you'll be making more than an average of 203K over the next 24 years?

[deleted]
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by MJR on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:45PM (#6003665)
I used 100K as an example showing even if you made that much a year 3% would still only be 72K over the 24 years. If you were only making 35K a year, say as a teacher, 100K in student loans would take a LONG time to pay off. With this program someone making 35K would only pay back a little over 25K into the program.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by count on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:30PM (#6003603)
Depends on the interest rate of the loan. No reason to pay it off early if you've got a 1-2% loan - you'd be better off in the long term investing that 'extra' money and getting 3-5% return.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by dangrossman on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:33PM (#6003617)
Where are you going to get a 1-2% student loan as an 18 year old with no credit or assets (or anyone else, really)? Government loans are 6.8% right now.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by count on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:40PM (#6003642)
You can't, now, I guess. My wife's consolidation loan is only 1.5% (well, 2% with a .5% discount for auto-online payment). We lucked out, I guess!
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by pfisch on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:16PM (#6003514)
At 100k salary why would it take 24 years to pay back a 72k loan?
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by MJR on Sunday July 07, 2013 @05:40PM (#6003648)
I used 100K as an example that even at that high of an income $3,000 a year only adds up to 72K. If you make 50K salary for 24 years you're still only paying 36K for your education. The program stats "students would pay 3 percent of their paycheck back for 24 years in order to help fund the program for future students".

With the direction higher education costs are moving, this could be a very inviting choice for those who would pay for college with student loans.

Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by smsm42 on Sunday July 07, 2013 @06:18PM (#6003810)
The problem here is that it is obvious there are a lot of students that would not be able to pay current tuition from their earnings. If there were none, current loan system would work perfectly. So there will be subsidizing. It works only if you dont know in which category you will fall - like with insurance. Once you know on which side of the equation you are - you will have definite incentives to either maximize or minimize use of this system, and this will make it unbalanced and unsustainable in the long run, since potential high earners would try to avid it - they have no upside there - and potential free riders would flock to it.
Re:Oregon Proposes Investment Model For Student Loans by jberryman on Sunday July 07, 2013 @06:12PM (#6003782)
> and I don't particulalry want to subsidize their education with my future earnings.

Then do you oppose the idea of public universities generally? Atlas Shrugged is a work of fantasy and light philosophy; I don't think it's relevant to the problem at hand.