bzzzt! Wrong!
Releasing stuff that is "close enough" as a product and have it succeed is wasting other people's lives as they struggle to fix your ball of mud and make it work better over time.
Better to wait and not waste other people's time.
Software (open or otherwise) is never done, its always too ugly, missing some features, slow and / or buggy.
If you are thinking about releasing your stuff as open source, do it now, it probably is too early and nobody will use it, someone may pick up it or your next library, share some knowledge report some bugs or evern fix stuff.
It is very easy for software developers to verify the stability of the libraries they are using, you have absolutely no responsibility to them by releasing software that has bugs, it all does.
It's entirely one thing to release functional and ugly code, it's entirely another to simply code dump broken crap and think that's a good thing.
If you open source some code without making any grandiose promises and someone somehow ends up in the position where they are wasting their time fixing it, its entirely their own decision / fault.
Not necessarily. A tarball of shit can become the de facto standard for some utility, and end up haunting us for ages after it gains critical mass, even long after a superior replacement arrives. See, e.g., rvm.
And ... I've got a pretty thick skin after years and years of net time, but I already struggle with staying motivated on projects, and that kind of feedback really doesn't help.
So, for the most part, the whole "social programming" thing is just not for me.
I don't think any of this negates your argument, but I understand the apprehension involved in open sourcing a project one feels is sub-par.
I realize if you want your project to flourish as an open source project, you need to make it palatable. However, a tarball of shit is better than NOTHING. This person isn't even deluding themselves by saying they'll "get around to open sourcing it." You won't do the world a disservice by releasing working code. Seriously, just come out and be honest and say "I don't want to open source it because I don't wanna."