News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by pyre on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:44PM (#5996175)

  > Because they could be updated
So, this is a rally against all extensions? Expanding this argument, we basically get to a point where we don't trust any software:

  1. No more browser extensions.
  2. Want ad-blocking in Firefox? Request feature.
  3. Feature request denied.
  4. Fork Firefox.
  5. Add ad-blocking to Firefox fork.
This leaves us with a couple of issues:

1. The bar to adding functionality to a browser has now been raised significantly. With a larger barrier to entry, we will see fewer extensions for trivial things like 'adding collapsible threads to HN', which can make your life easier, but isn't worth a fork of the entire browser to achieve.

2. Trust. You still have to trust the developer of the browser fork that same way that you have to trust the developer of the browser extension.

Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by coldtea on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:54PM (#5996219)
>So, this is a rally against all extensions? Expanding this argument, we basically get to a point where we don't trust any software:

Yes. So DON'T expand it. The thing is, third party updatable extensions are far less trustworthy than Firefox.

Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by pyre on Friday July 05, 2013 @09:42PM (#5997574)
This is true, but to only trust Firefox means that you only get features that Mozilla adds to Firefox.
Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by njharman on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:24PM (#5996347)
> this is a rally against all extensions?

No it is a rally against extensions which have a non-risky (and arguably) superior alternative.

Risk is a gradient and cumulative. The more risky things you do, the more at risk you are.

Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by gcb0 on Friday July 05, 2013 @06:51PM (#5997096)
Yes. As it always been for any software.

Host files: as secure as you can get. Whole network.

Browser extension: remote code exploit possibility. Probably not available for mobile. Trusting someone who takes money from Google...

Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by fpgeek on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:29PM (#5997828)
FYI, on mobile, Adblock Plus and Adblock Edge (among others) are available for mobile Firefox.
Re:Google paid AdBlock Plus to get its ads whitelisted by gcb0 on Saturday July 06, 2013 @02:42AM (#5998174)
For how many browsers?

And then they have even less community validation, rising the security tradeof even more