News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Restore the Fourth by rayiner on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:09PM (#5995485)
They didn't have phones back then, sure, but the concept of "your" effects transcends time. They had records about people stored by third parties back then, but chose to limit 4th amendment protections to things that belong to you. That distinction between "your" effects and anything referring to you can't be ignored.

Also, the 4th amendment does not use the phrase "not public." It gives four examples that are intensely private: your person, your home, your effects, your papers. How private is data that you share with hundreds of people you don't even know?

You can't ignore the plain words on the page for your version of what you think the "spirit" of the language is. The framers could have drafted the 4th amendment much more broadly even only accounting for information sources that existed back then. They did not sue that, And you have to give effect to this conscious choice. P

There are no comments on this comment yet.