News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by mattmanser on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:46AM (#5995357)
This isn't a politics discussion site and to top this off this is an extremist view which doesn't add anything to the discussion.

It's not even remotely related to the article.

Why is this not d/ved to oblivion? Are you even from France?

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by GuiA on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:06PM (#5995472)
I'm sorry, how is that an extremist view? Nowhere is he saying that we should all assassinate the president, or kill all the arabs, or anything resembling extremist views.

What he's stating are facts. Re-read the sentences one by one. They're the underpinnings of our society and they're no fun to hear, and most people don't even realize that they're there, but it's the reality of things.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by mattmanser on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:07PM (#5996271)
I'm not even vaguely interested in this discussion precisely because there are no facts in there, each point is an extreme interpretation of the world by someone who is clearly an anarchist.

Pick any one paragraph and approach it from a devil's advocate, try and argue against it yourself. For every one a clear counter point should immediately jump to you mind or you need to do some serious and unbiased research into history, politics and sociology.

That democratic governments are sued, that they do censure themselves, that politicians do resign in disgrace, that they are thrown out of power peacefully, that police officers are prosecuted for excessive force, that enquiries are done into police shootings, that many police forces fire less bullets in a year than a single gun enthusiast might in a week at the shooting range.

You'll rapidly see how preposterous the whole rant is. He claims that he cannot renegotiate the power they grant to their government. But anyone in a democracy can become a politician and gain that power or a political activist and energise a base until the government starts negotiating. But it cannot be a person on their own. They must be able to convince many others.

He just can't be bothered.

So no facts or reality, just an extreme political opinion not discussing the article at all, which is precisely why these discussions aren't a good fit for a programming, tech and startup board.

The post is very relevant, this thread, not.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by GuiA on Friday July 05, 2013 @04:00PM (#5996509)
You're not even trying. Maybe if you're "not even vaguely interested in [the] discussion", you shouldn't take part in it.

Sure you can argue for or against the double edged sword that is government– and I'm sure most "reasonable people" would argue for it. But saying that the basic tenets that oleganza wrote about are wrong is patently lying to yourself.

If you don't pay your taxes, don't agree with a court's verdict, don't pay a fine that you got– guess what, ultimately things will be resolved by holding you against your will in a little concrete cell, and if you try to get out of it, violence will be used against you.

> But anyone in a democracy can become a politician and gain that power or a political activist

Have you been following the news recently? Do you see what happens to activists? As for the argument "anyone can become politician and have power", I find staring at the pictures on this page to be pretty self-explanatory wrt that argument: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_United_States_...

You can dismiss it all if you want, but you're only fooling yourself.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:55AM (#5995405)
I live in Paris. My comment is extra-relevant because in every discussion of something that government does "wrong" people miss the big picture. The problem is not in some particular "bad action", but in concentration of violence.

Now, it's offensive that you call my view "extremist". It's not me who teaches you how to leave, makes apologies for taxation, inflation, controls, restrictions, violent intervention and threats. It is people with guns who are "extremists" because instead of seeking peaceful solutions, they "solve" everything by decree and a gun.

I will never ever pose a threat to you or your lifestyle. If you like your government, party or president - that's fine. I will never threaten you based on your beliefs. Now will you threaten me based on my beliefs? I don't want to participate in your club, receive "services" from it or support your laws or president. Will you respect me like I respect you?

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by rtpg on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:03PM (#5995452)
>It is people with guns who are "extremists" because instead of seeking peaceful solutions, they "solve" everything by decree and a gun.

Democracy is a pretty fucking peaceful solution in most developped nations to solve things. The guns are there to protect the democratic system, because if there's nothing like that, people have been shown to not follow the rules decided by the democratic system.

Empirical evidence is a lot more convincing than your personal theory on how things "should" work.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:13PM (#5995499)
"The guns are there to protect the democratic system"

You have just presented a justification for guy A killing guy B for now forking over his part of income to guy C.

Now you need to decipher "democratic system" and what does it mean in reality.

I my view, it's a label for a system where opinions of some people must be forced onto others using force based on some sophisticated paperwork called "voting".

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by rtpg on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:40PM (#5995621)
1. Collective action makes progress a lot easier 2. Democracy is the least worst way to do it 3. I'm fine with violence not being a free market value

I think you'll find that the large majority of people agree with the third point, and even without democracy, the will of the large majority will impose itself onto everyone except in very few cases.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:00PM (#5995706)
As I said in other threads, existence of things does not justify itself.

The fact that majority of people can force anyone in minority to comply does not say anything about morality.

I point out that people tell themselves that it is okay if majority seemingly "decide" to to allow someone to kill some people. I question that belief which oddly looks very similar to any religious dogma.

You advocate for "progress" and "democracy is the lest worst". I'm fine with it, live your life and participate in democracy. But let me politely disagree with you. Will you not participate in "majority" that tries to kill me if I don't give them my stuff?

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by embolism on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:37PM (#5995609)

   You have just presented a justification for guy A killing guy B for now forking over his part of income to guy C.
Without the government, activities like that will take place without any justification.
Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:56PM (#5995693)
First, it's an assertion without a proof.

Second, in other words you say "I don't know how to protect myself against random violence without centralized violence, I will advocate imposing that violence on everyone around."

Don't get me wrong. I don't advocate "guns are bad" or "guns are good" here. If you want to set up your protection club with helicopters and ninjas, I have nothing against. But do you say it must be imposed on me? Only because I somehow benefit under umbrella of your enterprise? In other words, you want to force me to pay for your business model when it's you who bothers about security and cannot figure out how to pay for it voluntarily.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by embolism on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:27PM (#5995809)
Taking your two answers together, it seems that hiring a security company to provide armed guards to protect me would be perfectly acceptable to you.

What's to stop consolidation amongst the security companies? What would prevent them from using their monopoly of force to set up whatever government they liked?

That's essentially how central government formed in the first place. Why wouldn't it just happen again?

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:49PM (#5995906)
Even if it could, is it a justification for it?

I think government is only possible when many believe it's good. It's not only raw violence. If people see violence they don't like it. That's why government tries hard hiding it under abstract concepts.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by embolism on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:28PM (#5996105)
What has justification got to do with anything?

People aren't arguing with you because they like the fact that the government uses force. The argument is that if you eliminated the government, the alternative (private dictatorships) would be even less accountable.

Certainly people are susceptible to a kind of strange loyalty to governments, but if you remove the government that won't just disappear. People will just become loyal to the most powerful mob for protection. That's what happened before. It's up to you to explain why it would be any different now.

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by eatitraw on Saturday July 06, 2013 @07:20AM (#5998586)
I think we already have "private" dictatorships in most of the world. 2/3 of states are fucked up, just look at failed state index or press freedom index.

> The argument is that if you eliminated the government, the alternative (private dictatorships) would be even less accountable.

If you are right and private defense organization would collapse into one, then why there is no single government? (Moreover, some of states(like USSR) get decomposed into few more, so the number of states even grows). Why do you assume there is no reason to prevent a number of PDO turning into violent one?

There are great books: Murray Rothbard's "For a new liberty: libertarian manifesto": http://mises.org/document/1010/

David Friedman's "The machinery of freedom": http://daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by embolism on Saturday July 06, 2013 @07:18PM (#6000392)
Actually we do have a overall decrease in the number of states over the past few centuries. The USSR is a special case because it was actually based on ideology and not just strength.

We can equally ask why, if your libertarian philosophy is so naturally stable, it has not emerged into the world yet?

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by eatitraw on Saturday July 06, 2013 @08:33PM (#6000561)
> Actually we do have a overall decrease in the number of states over the past few centuries.

It doesn't really affect my argument(if all states didn't collapse into one over past couple of centuries, then multi-government system is quite stable), but I am quite interested in the source(out of pure curiousity).

> The USSR is a special case because it was actually based on ideology and not just strength

Almost all states utilize some sort of ideology. In fact, I agree that ideological component was really strong in the USSR, but the USSR did use raw power - it annexed baltic states for example.

Also, there are other examples: Czechoslovakia, South & North Sudan.

> We can equally ask why, if your libertarian philosophy is so naturally stable, it has not emerged into the world yet?

I would define stable as "won't collapse once established". The problem of stability is orthogonal to the problem of establishing. It is not easy to organize a market anarchy when all territory is occupied by the state(note: you cannot easily organize another state either, though existing states are relatively stable). In past there were more or less "anarcho-capitalist" societies which lasted for thousands of years: medieval iceland, medieval ireland.

Iceland: http://wiki.mises.org/wiki/Iceland#Medieval_Iceland_and_Anar...

Ireland: http://pucksmith.blogspot.ru/2013/02/libertarian-ancient-ire...

Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by skue on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:06PM (#5995471)
Please stop calling it "offensive" when people have a strong reaction your views.
Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by oleganza on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:10PM (#5995490)
Fair enough.
Re:The state of democratic control over surveillance in France by goldfeld on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:33PM (#5995593)
Would you prefer distribution of violence?