Or, if he wants some of the upside, structure it as a convertible loan. That actually may be a better idea for both parties, rather than a straight up shares for work trade.
Plus, using 3-4x rates would be awful when talking to investors. The opportunity/contractor inflated rates would quickly dilute any investments over time.
EDIT: I'm agreeing with tptacek. Trying to compensate a part-time contractor to get founder-level equity (eg. 10%) in proportion to "time put in" would be bloody insane!
I'm arguing the contractor should be compensated fairly. We're going through this entire exercise because the founders don't want to pay the contractor a market wage. So the service that is rendered should either be structured as a loan (convertible or otherwise), or the contractor is compensated with shares proportional to the amount of work under a fair valuation of the company. Don't like those options? Pay the man for the work he did. What's the alternative? Work for free?
Oh I'm sure the startup would prefer deferred compensation, but it makes no sense for the contractor. He'd be taking all the risk.