News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker news. Great news site but what purpose does karma ... by brudgers on Thursday July 04, 2013 @02:37PM (#5991904)
Downvotes exist to curb destructive behavior.

Sometimes the destructive behavior is actual and embodied in the comment being downvoted.

Sometimes the destructive behavior is potential and in the person down voting.

I've downvoted bad comments. I've downvoted comments instead of arguing with them. I've downvoted comments because I was feeling ill-will toward the ideas it expressed, and I've even downvoted comments because I didn't hold good-will toward the poster.

In each of these cases, I had more destructive alternatives to the down vote. Was it fair? Well when a person has been around long enough, the recognize that these things even themselves out over time.

BTW, a community in which everyone votes in assent and descent according to some set of rules, isn't really voting.

There are no comments on this comment yet.