Re:ChatStep - Online Group Chat with Symmetric Key Encryption
by nealb on Thursday July 04, 2013 @01:26PM
(#5991593)
The good thing about symmetric key encryption in the browser is easy enough to check. You just need to make sure that messages/images are encrypted before being sent to the server, and that the password is never sent to the server. Also ChatStep uses sjcl so the crypto isn't homemade like CryptoCat.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ChatStep - Online Group Chat with Symmetric Key Encryption
by SamWhited on Thursday July 04, 2013 @01:35PM
(#5991635)
Sure, I can verify that things aren't being sent in plaintext, and I can verify that they're using sjcl, but I can't verify most of the other things I mentioned. How do I know they're using sjcl right and not introducing some vulnerability (yes, I know I can dig through their JavaScript, but that's a plain in the ass)? I'm not saying I think they've got any problems; I'm just saying, be careful.
These sorts of tools, while convenient, are dangerous without a proper understanding of what you're doing. User beware.