Europe (the continent) actually has a larger area (10,180,000 km² > 9,826,675 km²) and a much larger population (739.2 million > 313.9 million ) than the United States (the country).
I presume you mean the EU (which still has a much larger population) or maybe Western Europe? Or maybe North America (the continent)?
Personally, I think that Europe does have a lot more cultural diversity than the United States - but I can see that the point is arguable and that it's hardly a case of being "delusional" to argue the opposing point.
And if that's the case, treating the USA as a comparable EU country in terms of diversity ignores that diversity found here. Which is what was being discussed in the first place.
Still, I'd argue that the US is far more diverse than any single country of the EU, so treating the people of the US as all being the same is as silly as treating the people of the EU as all being the same.
Context, people, context.
Only in land area, and much of that extra land area is very sparsely populated. Europe has over twice as many people.
It probably depends on where you live. Here in PA, it's been a non-issue for me.
But then, be careful. America is much larger than Europe, and while we are all part of the same country, we aren't the same people. There are big difference among the different parts of the country, and making them out to be all the same would be like me using a single country and extrapolating that out to all countries in Europe.
Even still, I have religious friends, and non-religious friends. It's never come up, and never been an issue.