News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:23AM (#5985119)
I say block all US services in EU. It will be inconvenient as hell and incredibly annoying but it will give European companies a chance to fill the void.

And yes I know it can be bypassed but jumping through hoops is always annoying and if European alternatives show up people would be less likely to bother.

I would do it just to see what happens :)

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:38AM (#5985254)
No, the only real solution is for the EU to come up with its own proprietary replacement for the internet. Replace everything from HTML up to HTTP with closed source software built by EU governments. Remove any server or computer hardware either built in the US or built by a company that also services the US, and replace them with systems built in the EU. And since you can't trust American IT workers not to be NSA moles they'll have to expel all of them, revoke American visas and bar Americans from entry into any EU nation.

Only then will Europe be truly free.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by sneak on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:57AM (#5985387)
> Replace everything from HTML up to HTTP with closed source software built by EU governments.

The new boss looks surprisingly like the old boss, don't you think?

Also, you sort of lost me at closed-source, or are you being hyperbolic for sarcasm's sake?

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:02PM (#5985431)
Hyperbole and sarcasm.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by nikster on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:14PM (#5985519)
It's funny you would fall so hard for the mock outrage of our European politicians. Please.

If the US says jump, they say how high. They couldn't be happier the US is letting them join in their war games. The USA and Europe are united in their total servitude to big business - those who pay the bills call the tunes. Goldman Sachs is international, they've bought up Politicians on both sides of the pond. Same for other big players.

In the case of espionage - they are embarrassed; but the outrage displayed is just for show, and the "consequences" they speak of are just sound bites for the press. There isn't a thing more harmless than a threat by a European politician.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:34PM (#5985685)
I wasn't actually falling for it, I was mocking the breathless paranoia I've been seeing here of late.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Vivtek on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:14PM (#5986008)
It was kind of hard to be sure - the top post on this thread is literally calling for the expulsion of all Americans from Europe.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:22PM (#5986087)
Poe's Law has come home to roost on Hacker News...
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by mitchty on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @03:46PM (#5987081)
At this point I've basically decided this whole thing has moved past Logos here to complete Pathos. That top post is somewhat disheartening to be honest as it seems to wholeheartedly ignore even Europes own sordid past.

I'm sure there will be fallout but sometimes I swear there is a latent anger from certain Europeans on the Internet, note I've never seen this in person yet or to the degree I see online, that makes me feel like all Americans are being viewed as some sort of demonic entity. I'm starting to think vacations to Europe aren't a good idea because I'm getting a completely unnerving vibe that I'll be viewed that way just for visiting.

Aka: the exact same thing people from Europe have been saying about never visiting the USA for reason XYZ. The vitriol is starting to make me want to just visit Russia or China or anywhere else instead. If people don't want to be civil about where I live fine, I can be pathological too.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:44AM (#5985303)
I personally love interoperability and open standards I never said we have to reinvent the wheel but if part of the wheel is broken (like the US spying on us) we need to replace it.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:02PM (#5985425)
Yes but you can't fix a wheel by cutting the axle. Not every US company is engaged in spying, and the US has ways of spying that go beyond web services. Also, the precedent this would set in terms of politicizing global access to the internet, to me, would be no less egregious than what the US is doing. How long, after that, does every disagreement between nations result in wars of packet-dropping or malicious routing?

That said, something a bit less drastic might well do some good for the world. Instead of blocking everything, block google and facebook for a day, just to show they can and they're serious. Or even just threaten to. Anything that causes the powerful companies that American politicians actually listen to to maybe lose money might lead to some real action.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:10PM (#5985491)
I think you're overestimating the US's role on the internet.

Look at china they seem to be doing ok although their reasons are completely the wrong ones for doing it.

Yes a blockade for a couple of days would be a good idea however I'm afraid Europeans are being underestimated by the US so if we don't have the determination to stick to it it's not worth doing.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by krapp on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:31PM (#5985662)
But why assume that these European replacements for American web services wouldn't either be complicit in spying for their home countries, or the US? Why is a Great Firewall of Europe better for Europeans' own freedom?
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by sentenza on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:10PM (#5985973)
Because of accountability. And I am much more confident about the EU than the US regarding the possibility of stopping the surveillance dystopia.

Yes, bad things happen over here too, but the indifference of the public has received a huge dent, with the lid now blown off the BND and GCHQ stuff. Also remember, that privacy is a huge issue for the general populace in some countries (Germany, Poland, Bulgaria).

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by rhizome on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:08PM (#5985957)
Not every US company is engaged in spying

Every company that is subject to NSLs and the like are either already spies or spies-in-waiting.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by muyuu on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:37AM (#5985240)
I think a forced warning that your data is going to be held in US servers would work. Similar to the cookie warning that is compulsory here in the UK - otherwise your site risks getting blocked.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by gst on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:29AM (#5985164)
Censorship is always the solution. Because the user does not know what he wants. Is this what you want to say?
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:33AM (#5985197)
Face it there is already censorship and people pretending its for a noble cause like to prevent piracy or child porn or whatever I'm just taking it to its logical next step. Protecting your countries users from foreign spying.

Edit: I'm not saying its right but if we're already doing the wrong thing why not make it entertaining and beneficial to local business.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by mc32 on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @11:48AM (#5985326)
So you're saying if other countries' data traffic did not pass through the US the US would be unable to set-up some shop over there to syphon data?

And A US company could not be allowed to buy an EU company?

It's all shortsighted and all these 'measures' could be overcome, if there's incentive for it.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:01PM (#5985421)
I would love to see the US try to set up shop in the EU in order to spy on its citizens. Now that would be an entertaining international incident. A US company not being able to buy a EU company is an interesting side effect that may promote diversity and innovation. Have you heard of speciation? Also everything can be overcome however it would make it considerably more difficult for the US to conduct mass surveillance on EU citizens.
Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by mc32 on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:12PM (#5985506)
You don't have to hope for it. It already happens.

Companies spy on each other sometimes with the help of intelligence services[1]. When CN or RU or the US or DE, etc. set up shop, they don't officially announce it. And if the EU decided to embargo US services, there would be more incentive to do this kind of espionage. But it's all moot. Most, if not all secret intelligence services share at least some data with each other. It's to each other's benefit. It makes each other's jobs easier and it helps them circumvent laws technically forbidding them from directly spying on their own citizens.

The US does not really care to surveil EU citizens, so much as the EU prefers the US do their dirty work for them (and vice versa). That's separate from intelligence gathering and industrial espionage but they all have these mutual understandings.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_espionage

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:36PM (#5985698)
> I would love to see the US try to set up shop in the EU in order to spy on its citizens.

I think that the usual practice with foreign intelligence services setting up shop in target countries is to avoid being seen.

OTOH, if you don't think an agency specifically chartered to gather foreign signals intelligence which is recently the subject of controversy for allegedly exceeding its mandate by its conduct of secret domestic signals intelligence gathering is somehow timid about doing the thing it is specifically chartered to do, I'd be interested in hearing why.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by Fuxy on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:59PM (#5985880)
Ok lets assume you're right and the US manages to splice into fiber optic cables in the country they target and for some absurd reason no human being ever checks the fiber optic cables which are easily accessible over land how would they send all that data back for processing?

Or if they do it locally how the hell do they get all that equipment in without being noticed?

When you're doing surveillance in a foreign country you can't be extravagant you have to choose your targets carefully.

I'm against mass surveillance for the hell of it I know there will always be a certain degree of surveillance i just want them out of average peoples lives they have no business being there.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:07PM (#5985947)
> Ok lets assume you're right and the US manages to splice into fiber optic cables in the country they target

I don't recall ever saying anything about the US managing to splice into fiber optic cables, or any other particular mechanism of gathering signals intelligence.

Re:German minister: Stop using U.S. Web services to avoid NS... by danmaz74 on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @12:28PM (#5985638)
Yes, I'm sure that an economic war is what we need right now.