Depending on how close you were to the heliport to start out with, say favorably it's a 10 minute walk/cab ride to the helipad, 15 minutes for security and waiting for the helicopter, 10-15 minute flight, 10 minutes to get back airside, 5-10 minutes to the right terminal, reclear security, etc. and it's almost an hour or more in total.
From most places in midtown or lower, it's vastly more convenient to have a black car pick you up and drop you off right in front of your terminal in an hour or so, depending on traffic, while you read, do work, or finish a conference call. You just get in the car, and get out at the other side, clear security once, and go to your gate.
The only time I used it was when I had a meeting a few minutes away from the helipad, I had an international flight I had to make, and traffic was all screwed up due to some major accident, google maps saying it would be 2 hours to get to the airport.
New York Helicopter will get you there now, at $875 per person, 2 minimum, but only to the GA terminal. I don't know how they expect you to get from there to your gate.