I ask the question in one line and ask for a one line response. its upto then if they want to provide more information.
Providing context is, as a rule of thumb, a bad idea. It takes time to read it, and that's the exact opposite of the point of a one-liner. If it's necessary for answering the question, then chances are the question is too broad or poorly targeted: your recipient ought to already have the necessary context. That's what makes them useful for asking your question.
That said, it's just a guideline, which means break it when you feel like breaking it.
Everyone is going to have a different threshold for what seems rude, what seems worth answering, and so on; you kinda have to go with hit or miss. Only this past week, I actually got a response back from an author I emailed over a month ago. I had stopped expecting a response two days after I sent it off and moved on, so it was a very pleasant surprise.
My last email went something like this
Subject: One line response needed only Body: Hi X,
Could you please tell me what you consider a healthy user activation rate?
Thank you
Regards
---
That's it. Of course, that's not how I would email everyone.
Just email one specific question.
Then a week or so later, email another specific question. Repeat.
I've been saying no to all "pick your brain" requests, and even interview requests, but if someone emails a specific question, I answer it. (I'm at [email protected] if you want to test this.)
One guy wanted an interview, I said no (just too busy), so he emailed just one question, then did it again, and a month or so later he posted our interview: http://onepercentcollective.org/derek-sivers-generosity-talk...
I thought that was a pretty clever hack. Clever enough that I then met with him later, and he's an impressive dude.