Yes, use the technology wherever applicable, knowing that the technology does not guarantee correctness. But definitely stop the wiretapping and the collection of (even encrypted) data.
The tech doesn't justify the program.
It shouldn't be.
However that has nothing to do with whether we should attempt to control NSA dragnet surveillance with technology after the fact, or help to construct a surveillance state in the first place. Debating whether we should apply controls to access to say phone record data collected by the government ignores the more important question of whether that data should be collected and collated by the NSA in the first place. I'd say that collection of the data is the only point at which adequate safeguards can be put in place, not after consumption of the data - by then it is too late, and any technical safeguards can easily be put aside later.
It's almost like there was a reason I explicitly disclaimed NSA when I made the point you responded to.
Even besides the IRS, what about FBI, local law enforcement, ATF, Border Patrol, and all of those other Federal agencies that have arrest powers? Should the local Good ol' Boy sheriff be able to pull up your record in NCIC with no audit trail?
Not collecting all that information in a central record is the best defence against misuse - if you collect it, it will at some point in the future be misused, just as Hoover, Nixon, the GDR etc misused the far more limited powers they were given.
Indeed, and it's concerning that Lessig is able to reply to those types of points in very clear and direct language and still have it fly over the heads of people because "PALANTIR".
Even completing ignoring the very concept of the NSA it is clear that the government will be adopting technology to handle the governance of people.
So decide, tech peoples: Should this technology build in audit trails or not? Should this technology record what interface a government employee was using to extract this data, or not?
There are practically no government databases which can be completely innocuous in the face of a determined government insider. Don't throw the baby of technology controls on misuse of data out with the bathwater of... something(?), especially with accusations as specious as "their board member knows a guy who was on the board of... BAE! (oooooh ahhhhhhh)"