Re:Encryption Has Foiled Wiretaps for First Time Ever, Feds Say
by DefectiveDesign on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:23AM
(#5965210)
It was broken before it hits the shelf.
"They do not use(release) code, they can't crack"
Re:Encryption Has Foiled Wiretaps for First Time Ever, Feds Say
by nknighthb on Sunday June 30, 2013 @10:36AM
(#5965912)
Are you alleging the NSA is violating its mandate by deliberately leaving top secret information vulnerable?
Re:Encryption Has Foiled Wiretaps for First Time Ever, Feds Say
by mpyne on Sunday June 30, 2013 @11:11AM
(#5966013)
Not only that, but he's also alleging that NSA developed AES.
Re:Encryption Has Foiled Wiretaps for First Time Ever, Feds Say
by nknighthb on Sunday June 30, 2013 @12:23PM
(#5966259)
Read in a literal sense, that is true, but the NSA has sufficient influence to exercise an effective veto over mass-market crypto just by saying they don't believe it's secure (whether that is true or not). If the NSA said "don't use AES", most people wouldn't use AES. They also could have easily spooked everyone off Rijndael during the AES selection process.
For that reason, I don't generally find it useful to argue the point of exactly where Rijndael actually came from.
Re:Encryption Has Foiled Wiretaps for First Time Ever, Feds Say
by diroussel on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:48AM
(#5969774)
Well it highly unlikely that they were not involved in the selection process for AES, so in a sense they did develop AES.
Also with Suite B, the NSA tells you want eliptic curve parameters to use. They may have chosen those parameters to suit there needs, should be need to break the encryption.
It's an open question whether strong crypto used inappropriately makes people do things they wouldn't otherwise. If you know all comms are monitored, and don't ever say anything incriminating on the phone, you're better off than someone who has an unbreakable encrypted phone but is talking to an informant with a recorder on the other end.