Re:Join Oliver Stone and Noam Chomsky in Urging Correa to Gr...
by _djo_ on Saturday June 29, 2013 @10:40AM
(#5962490)
Manning falls under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Snowden does not. That alone means that he cannot be treated the same before his trial. It especially means he cannot be tortured or denied legal representation.
I still have faith in the US's civilian courts to deliver a fair verdict in Snowden's case, despite its flaws.
Re:Join Oliver Stone and Noam Chomsky in Urging Correa to Gr...
by sneak on Saturday June 29, 2013 @10:43AM
(#5962503)
You are now obviously being willfully blind. Nothing about the military justice system makes torture or executive-branch verdict prognostication legal.
...and as for "fair", it doesn't even pass the laugh test.
There is zero to indicate they will treat Snowden or Assange or Greenwald fairly in any way.
Re:Join Oliver Stone and Noam Chomsky in Urging Correa to Gr...
by frozenport on Saturday June 29, 2013 @05:32PM
(#5963769)
Being in the military makes executive-branch verdict legal. For example if a soldier disobeys orders you can shoot him.
Also, Ecuador's status as free/not free is a red herring - he should be granted asylum simply so that he can avoid being tortured while in US custody, something they have demonstrated they are more than willing to do to leakers.
Also, it is difficult to concede your point about facing the US legal system even if I agreed with your basic premise, considering the embarrassing and reprehensible treatment of Bradley Manning.
From months of torture to a show trial (he was publicly declared guilty by Obama before his trial even started), even if we were in agreement that Snowden MAY have done anything wrong (which we aren't), to suggest that the US legal system at present is in any way resembling something that can produce justice in these matters is disingenuous at best and maliciously jingoistic at worst.