News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The State of the Tau by jessriedel on Friday June 28, 2013 @05:24PM (#5960426)
What's the worse historical accident of mathematics?
Re:The State of the Tau by thetwiceler on Friday June 28, 2013 @11:30PM (#5961413)
The use of infinitesimals in calculus! Things like integrating against "dx" or taking a derivative of a function "df/dx" make calculus seem like something it's not. Worse, it really introduces a whole new language whose rules for manipulation are unclear.

Like if we have a function f(x,y), we often write the "total" derivative of f as df = (df/dx) dx + (df/dy) dy And the rules for manipulating a differential like this are quite strange (e.g., dx on top cannot cancel the dx on bottom).

There's a language of differential forms that makes this notation a bit more rigorous, but I still think the notation is very misleading and confusing, especially for those who begin to learn calculus.

Re:The State of the Tau by currymesurprise on Saturday June 29, 2013 @09:39AM (#5962347)
To be fair to mathematics, in your example the proper notation is df = (del f/del x) dx + (del f/del y) dy, which does not suggest the possibility of cancelation.
Re:The State of the Tau by kryten on Saturday June 29, 2013 @03:42AM (#5961722)
This. Notation in formal mathematics is just totally awful. You pick on a great example as well there.