It's 2013, Google is a lot smarter and there are more ways to explain the varying quality of community sites. Note how Neocities is all subdomains.
You're also assuming that everybody wants to get search traffic. Everything on Facebook has a PageRank of NaN, and yet people still post. What if the whole point is to make pages about your pet cat, just because?
Maybe an interesting strategy would be to make the whole site NOINDEX by default. Turning off NOINDEX could be a premium feature. (Of course this could fail utterly as the customers that Neocities wants probably don't distinguish between URLs and search queries.)
> It's 2013, Google is a lot smarter and there are
> more ways to explain the varying quality of community
> sites. Note how Neocities is all subdomains.
Yes, Google is more sophisticated about how they derank web sites (I like to think that our small search engine, blekko.com, helped them see how poor their results had become on highly contested searches), but the spammers and the crooks have also upped their game such that many innocent sites get caught in the crossfire. (Google "panda killed my web site" for example). Not to mention the new trend of 'negative SEO' where someone might script a neocities site creator that triggered one of Google's anti-rank defenses and to destroy the organic rank of an otherwise pleasant web site. > You're also assuming that everybody wants to get
> search traffic. Everything on Facebook has a
> PageRank of NaN, and yet people still post. What
> if the whole point is to make pages about your
> pet cat, just because?
Actually I'm not making that assumption at all. Facebook pages have a NaN pagerank because facebook has a robots.txt that says "don't crawl us" and legit search engines respect that. Facebook rightly presumes that you will see your friends content because of mechanisms they have in place to put it in front of your eyes. And I also think that people making a page about their pet cat, or their belief in UFOs or whatever is fine and neocities is great for that. I'm just saying that the bad actors won't leave it alone for those people to play in it. > Maybe an interesting strategy would be to make
> the whole site NOINDEX by default. Turning off
> NOINDEX could be a premium feature. (Of course
> this could fail utterly as the customers that
> Neocities wants probably don't distinguish
> between URLs and search queries.)
Actually the same people who put their pet pictures up will probably not put meta tags in their HTML. The Neocities folks could put a robots.txt file that excluded search engines (like Facebook does) as well. But think through what you are saying.The person you want to make this "fun" for is a non-technologist putting up a page about their cat, and for people who are looking for random pages about cats. Or perhaps relatives of that person who say "Hey, Mindy put up a web site for her cat!", "Oh really? What's the address?", "I don't know, just Google 'Mindys Many Cats'", "Thats weird it doesn't find it", "Are you sure you spelled Mindy right?"
You see that non-technical crowd has been trained that Google finds everything, and if it doesn't find neocities websites then the neocities guys have to explain to Mindy why that is, which is going to be a complicated discussion because we've assumed for this discussion that Mindy is non-technical. Of course they could offer that as a pay service but that wouldn't work to well either since Mindy isn't going to put up a website for her cats and pay $1/month to do it.
So the neocities folks could curate the sites, and try to delete sites that are bad (they already do some of that) but that takes people and time. People + time == money, and for a free service money is hard to find. And then they say "Hmm, I wonder if Yahoo shut down Geocities not because they were clueless but instead because they actually started to see what they had gotten into and now they were scared they couldn't keep it going."
There is a whole bunch of "web" below the fun part. That the fun part is lacking is not because Geocities was shuttered.
I think you're the one thinking like a programmer here. It's not learning HTML that's fun, but rather learning how to build your own website and then seeing it online.
> Everything on Facebook has a PageRank of NaN
The universal truth is that people that post stuff online want an audience, which is why it doesn't matter if posts on Facebook do not have a page-rank, since it functions like a mailing-list - you post stuff and your connections then see it.
On the other hand Google's search engine is getting better and better at giving people what they want, slowly killing the long-tail in the process.
Which is why I sort of agree with you. For creative/obscure/personal websites, Google's search engine is useless and people that want to discover surprises are better off joining communities that happen with services like Reddit, or Twitter.
Nobody cares about that BS.
The fun part was in the CONTENT, not the technology.
So two things that are important to note here, the first is that the 'fun' part of the web was learning new things and static HTML, even dressed up with HTML5 goodies, will be fun if you don't know these technologies but no more or less fun than doing the same thing on a Raspberry Pi or something similar. Its the 'learning' that is fun, and the web was more 'fun' when you were learning it because it was all new, and once you learned enough about it to see it for what it was, the parts that are less seemly start to dominate your vision and it feels less fun. Which brings us to the second part.
The second part, and I don't have a good solution for this, is that folks will use this, and they will put good content on them and they will get page views and searches and what not. Then the 'link authority' of neocities will start to rise because, well it has a bunch of good content.
Once it crosses a threshold (which is sadly pretty low) then a crap ton of SEO types will start creating pages on it to boost the organic rating of various web sites. And then Google will penalize neocities, and the good stuff will become unfindable (on Google at least) because Google won't index it, or they will pump down host rank to the point where it shows up on the results on page 3.
Just prior to that people will build sites on it that do drive by malware injection using javascript. The preferred cloaking vector for that these days seems to be a script reference that points out to something that looks like jquery but really isn't.
Then the owner is going to get a lot of threatening letters from lawyers who were told by people who got hijacked to "get the bastards who did this!" and the bad guys will be well cloaked but the neocities ownership will be just standing there, an easy target (for hassling at least, register your DMCA agent right now if you haven't already to avoid the copyright trolls).
And at the end of the day the real reason the web isn't fun anymore will become apparent. There is too much money to be made by manipulating it, and so its full of bad actors who are chortling away while stealing billions of dollars from hapless 'lusers.'