Re:A Debian GNU/Hurd snapshot
by papsosouid on Thursday June 27, 2013 @03:50PM
(#5954341)
Monolithic kernels don't "focus on correctness". Some people might when writing one, plan 9 for example. But plenty don't, like linux as the most obvious example.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Reading the Plan 9 kernel code hasn't convinced me that its authors focused on correctness. The kernel code is pretty, and its twenty-year-old architecture could pass as only ten years old; but even excluding drivers, there is no shortage of bugs.
Re:A Debian GNU/Hurd snapshot
by papsosouid on Friday June 28, 2013 @09:56AM
(#5957970)
You found lots of bugs reading the plan 9 kernel source, and forgot to report them?
Interestingly, important parts of the Linux kernel are proven correct (e.g. the scheduler). But yeah...not the whole thing.
Re:A Debian GNU/Hurd snapshot
by papsosouid on Friday June 28, 2013 @09:57AM
(#5957973)
What? When and where has any part of linux been proven correct?
What I mean is that they try to achieve stability by eliminating bugs, not by doing damage control. Proactive vs reactive.
Re:A Debian GNU/Hurd snapshot
by papsosouid on Friday June 28, 2013 @12:08PM
(#5958711)
And what I mean is that is simply not true. Monolithic kernels give us unstable systems like windows, linux, BSDs, etc. Virtually ever highly reliable operating system is built on a microkernel.