News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by rdl on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:21PM (#5953092)
Technically this probably should be tagged as (2009). It's also technically a (TOP SECRET/STLW/ORCON/NOFORN) document, so if you have a clearance, you shouldn't be viewing it. (if you don't have a clearance, you also shouldn't be viewing it, but that's someone else's problem...)
Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by leot on Thursday June 27, 2013 @01:50PM (#5953655)
Those with a clearance can just glance at the top of the document and see that they shouldn't read it, right?

The only reason to worry is if you believe that your accessing of this document is being tracked by the authorities ...

Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by chockablock on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:48PM (#5953254)
Pretty remarkable that this means that folks with a clearance will end up with less information than those without one.

Is this a commonly-discussed problem in the security world? Is there an exception granted for publicly-disseminated information (such as leaks published in newspapers)?

Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by user2305832 on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:56PM (#5953306)
There is no exception. When Wikileaks posted its cables, the government mandated that anyone with a clearance shall not visit the websites and view the information. If it happened, it would be classified as a "data spill" which means classified info on a network with a lower classification.

"Data spills" sometimes result in punishment. If the mods read this comment, please return the classification to the title as it would ensure people with clearances were warned about the classification of the information contained.

Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by leephillips on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:07PM (#5954703)
"please return the classification to the title as it would ensure people with clearances were warned'

A fairly pointless precaution, as the prohibited material appears all over once it's publicly disseminated, including in places like the NY Times. I worked in a government lab when the first round of Wikileaks happened, and I got the memo: don't search out the material, don't read it even if you find it in the newspaper, etc. But the security people weren't completely crazy, so if you visited the front page of the Washington Post and there happened to be some stuff on there that was still classified, it wasn't treated as a security incident.

Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by webwanderings on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:34PM (#5953163)
A publicly clickable link can only be clicked. Imagine if you consciously don't want to click but your toddler nearby messes with your keyboard and clicks the link. Do you then become suspicious due to no fault of your own?
Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by rdl on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:40PM (#5953201)
I put the classification legend in the submission title, but the editor elves deleted it.
Re:ST-09-0002 NSA/CSS OIG Draft about Stellar Wind (2009) [pdf] by totalforge on Thursday June 27, 2013 @02:02PM (#5953724)
You could right-click on the link and view where it goes. Do you become suspicious from your toddler's click? Yes, yes you do. Not actionable in itself, but it will be on your secret file you can't see, forever.