Re:California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti...
by ianterrell on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:08PM
(#5949065)
> You can't spray paint over a billboard and then claim you're protected under the first amendment, for example.
Why not? The court doesn't have to agree that your claim is valid. To prohibit you from even making that claim seems preposterous.
Re:California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti...
by tptacek on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:15PM
(#5949127)
The claim isn't relevant to the statute. At a jury trial, you're not allowed to make irrelevant arguments.
Re:California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti...
by xanderstrike on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:10PM
(#5949086)
The article says he spent six months doing it a few times a week. I think that qualifies as a habitual repeat offender.
Re:California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti...
by zhemao on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:31PM
(#5949246)
He's only a repeat offender if what he's doing is actually an offense. I don't think you could consider chalking a public sidewalk to be a criminal offense, unless you're willing to say that a kid who draws a hopscotch pad on his/her neighborhood sidewalk is a juvenile offender.
Re:California man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti...
by shock-value on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:14PM
(#5949121)
Oh okay, I must have glossed over that line. 13 years is still way too much (obviously), but that guy should not be surprised that he's going to be prosecuted and receive some kind of punishment.
That being said, I don't even know that I'd consider writing with washable chalk to be vandalism. Maybe "littering" or something, considering how easy it is to wash off. Certainly nothing that should warrant any jail time (unless you're talking about a habitual repeat offender or something).