News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by kamakazizuru on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:08PM (#5946908)
am I the only one who doesnt find the sites that similar after all? Or to put it another way - neither of them seem particularly unique (fixed header, slider on top, broad sections and large footer) compared to many marketing sites these days?
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by eranation on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:19PM (#5946977)
Nope, I'm with you. I've seen much more obvious plagiarisms. Although it's obvious that Kintek were more than a little inspired by infinum, and indeed some items look copied as is except the color change, the rest looks like any other bootstrap / grid based marketing site template. They might have pushed the "inspiration" part to the limit, and might deserve the post for not being too original, but I'm sure you can find thousands of sites that have similar elements and statistically, some of them copied from someone else. And I'm sure infinium were also inspired (even subconsciously) from other designers.

Almost every other site today has a dark header, a Mac screen / laptop carousel, slide scroll / parallax / infinite scrolling and a 3 column grid using the same icon fonts, dark 3 column footer with links, partners / as seen on techcrunch / customer logos in gray emboss. everyone has it. Although it's clear they copied, you could find sites that have these elements that didn't copy (or copied from someone else). So it's just the number of similar elements that is annoying, not each element individually IMHO.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by moneyrich2 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @06:04PM (#5949435)
no, if you go to the home page, the first advert in the 2nd page says "100+ projects".

then from the article they link an early mockup of the clone site, it says right there "100+ projects"

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by jmharvey on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:33PM (#5947539)
Styles, like fashion, follow trends. But the similarities on these sites go well beyond just similar trends, especially once you're beyond the main page. The copy on the "Services" page is probably the most damning:

  We provide a wide array of software design and development
  services -- from Mobile applications and Web applications
  to User interface design, Quality assurance and Digital
  Strategy -- we're a trusted partner helping you develop
  your business.
vs

  We provide a wide array of Award Winning design and
  development services -- from Digital Strategy, QA and UX
  Design to iOS, Android, and Facebook Apps, Responsive
  Mobile Enhanced Websites, Ecommerce and Business
  Automation Tools -- we're your trusted partner in Digital.
I don't think anyone honestly believes those sentences were written independently of each other. Look at them in their context on the page, and the plausibility of coincidental design similarity goes even further out the window. This was clearly a copy/paste/edit job.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by shelltreader on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:13PM (#5947831)
That's not good enough; it's too common. Sentence structure can't be copyrighted, just as common design elements can't be copyrighted. Show us HTML or CSS blocks that are exactly the same or slightly tweaked on both websites.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by Smudge on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:43PM (#5950216)
It's not "damning" because that sentence structure, in particular, can't be copyrighted. It's "damning" because it is one very obvious part of a larger whole which, compounded, make it very unlikely that these two sites were developed independently. You could argue that Kintek changed it just enough to make it not plagiarism or copyright violation, but that's not exactly the point.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by andyhmltn on Thursday June 27, 2013 @04:58AM (#5951276)
Hash both the images that are used to create that curved hero unit thing they both have. They both come out as e6a486ac74a59aaa1abefec33de40c55
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by ricardobeat on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:38PM (#5950196)
Have you even looked at them? The top banner has rectangular links that are the same, as do the 3-column icons and the footer.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by gngeal on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @03:02PM (#5948219)
By "damning", are you referring to the parroting of the silly use of capital letters?
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by mintplant on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:39PM (#5947149)
- The scrolling animations on the header are exactly the same.

- The curved/depressed backgrounds behind the hero image (fairly unique) are the same shape and style.

- Page sizing is the same.

- Color scheme is the same, with blue swapped out for red.

These are just from glancing quickly between the two sites. Combined with the overall similarity, the fact that the scrolling animation is exactly the same is the most damning evidence that they deliberately copied the other site.

Also, compare http://www.infinum.co/services with http://kintek.com.au/showcase/ - specifically, the "home > showcase" nav.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by sauravc on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:08PM (#5947367)
Sure. But I've seen these design elements all over the web before. Infininum is just as guilty as Kintek when it comes to copying.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by Smudge on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:28PM (#5950162)
Your sentence is made up of letters and symbols that are used in hundreds (thousands, millions) of books and writings around the world. How dare you copy them. Come up with your own alphabet.

(My point: It's not the individual elements that matter. It's the unique combination. Infinum may not be exactly trend-setting, but unless you can find a site constructed with the exact same combination of design details, I say that Infinum is nowhere near as guilty when it comes to copying.)

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by mehwoot on Thursday June 27, 2013 @02:46AM (#5950990)
They admitted that they copied Infininum's website specifically- http://kintek.com.au/blog/getting-egg-on-your-face/
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by shelltreader on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:29PM (#5947983)
Err, their color schemes are not the same. And stop glancing at it. I want to see something real that's shows deliberate plagiarism.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by Smudge on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:36PM (#5950190)
The color schemes are actually quite similar.

Where Infinum uses #333, Kintek uses #313131. Where Infinum uses rgb(34, 34, 34), Kintek converts it to hex and uses #222222. The only major difference I can find is the highlight color, which is obvious. (red vs. blue)

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by kamakazizuru on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:35PM (#5947549)
yes they are similar - but for me theres a much bigger difference between similar / inspired design and flat out plagiarism - which this isnt.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by Udo on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:56PM (#5947279)
You're not alone. In fact, at first I thought their sites were standard Wordpress templates. I was kind of surprised they actually built them by hand. They both consist solely of what I would consider standard elements and layouts.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by muloka on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:25PM (#5947490)
I am pretty certain that the Kintek website is a Wordpress site built using the Roots Starter Theme.

Based on the fact they use:

* Make use of both the Yoast SEO and Gravity Forms plugins, which are well known Wordpress plugins.

* Twitter Bootstrap

* Have an /assets/ folder which most likely rewrites to /wp-content/themes/themename/assets/

* Have a /plugins/ folder which most likely rewrites to /wp-content/plugins/

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by notahacker on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:19PM (#5947452)
Did nobody asking this question look at this screenshot: http://www.infinum.co/system/uploads/2013-06/kintek/kintek-f...

Look at the area immediately below the fold.

It's one of the most blatant examples of plagiarism I've ever seen.

It's arguably worse than simple wholesale lifting of css, since they've carefully and deliberately redrawn distinctive design elements, and lifted half the copy as well

And this is a medium-sized design company, in a developed country. And it got nominated for an award.

Sure, the design has evolved a bit since it started as a direct copy, and the design wasn't that original in the first place, but I'm baffled by people suggesting the similarities might have been accidental.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by 205guy on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @04:29PM (#5948796)
Um, did you know that "awards" in the software industry are a sort of marketing gray area where companies pay a lot for a submission to some "organization" who then hands out "awards" and "nomiations" that can be advertized on websites?
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by notahacker on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:00PM (#5949007)
"Awards" in many industries are marketing grey areas. In this case, though, it's just yet another free css design gallery: the only notable thing being that kintek probably nominated themselves, knowing exactly where their original design came from...
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by jamesbritt on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:49PM (#5949351)
...where companies pay a lot ...

Hell, I kept getting spam regarding assorted awards my software "won" simply because I provided some sort of XML file indicating download details.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by DanBC on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @07:20PM (#5949761)
Have you seen this 2007 thing about the awards scam?

(http://successfulsoftware.net/2007/08/16/the-software-awards...)

> I put out a new product a couple of weeks ago. This new product has so far won 16 different awards and recommendations from software download sites. Some of them even emailed me messages of encouragement such as “Great job, we’re really impressed!”. I should be delighted at this recognition of the quality of my software, except that the ‘software’ doesn’t even run. This is hardly surprising when you consider that it is just a text file with the words “this program does nothing at all” repeated a few times and then renamed as an .exe. The PAD file that described the software contains the description “This program does nothing at all”.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by duiker101 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:28PM (#5947016)
That's pretty much the feeling I had... I would even say that it might be that kintek never heard of this guys, they just happened to have very similar idea that probably came from similar sources.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by thejosh on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:31PM (#5947041)
I don't think they look similar at all..

How many sites look like the Stripe landing page now adays?

Also, it's about 3am in brisbane at the moment, so you might not get a response for another 7 hours.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by tracker1 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:34PM (#5948034)
Looking at the code, it looks like the Infinum site is using a bootstrap base, but a fairly customized navbar, and that the kintek site is using something else... the structure of the markup is similar, but definitely different, as well as the difference in CSS classes.

Yes, there are similarities, but I have no reason to believe that one is a ripoff of another. They're both pretty bog-standard bootstrap-like marketing sites.

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by andyhmltn on Thursday June 27, 2013 @04:57AM (#5951275)
It may not seem like it is copied, but it definitely is. Take a look at the background image that gives that curved effect. They haven't just tried to recreate it, they've literally downloaded the same image and just used that.

If you hash both files on the original website and the new one, you'll see they both amount to: e6a486ac74a59aaa1abefec33de40c55

What more proof is needed? Haha

Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by websitescenes on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:01PM (#5947315)
Yes, I just posted the same sentiments before I saw your comment.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by mxxx on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:51PM (#5950051)
while it certainly looks like the second one did indeed rip off the first, i'd have to say there's nothing at all about the first one that looks even remotely interesting or innovative to me. looks like a run-of-the-mill $20 wordpress template.
Re:How to properly plagiarize a website by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:18PM (#5946970)
Yes