News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clojure Tradeoffs by gtrak on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:52AM (#5944269)
Yes, you're right. Tradeoffs was more of a theme than a commitment to being comprehensive. I guess I meant to portray design tradeoffs and their implications, and sort of what perceptions I have about them. It wasn't meant to speculate about what could have happened if different choices were made, or where I feel I'm missing out, or even to be super-objective. The main message was that the interaction of the design tradeoffs guides our subjective aesthetics, and those subjective inclinations result in our programs. Plus, I just wanted to compress the case for clojure for different people, in terms of clojure's design tradeoffs and their implications.
Re:Clojure Tradeoffs by plinkplonk on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:58AM (#5944281)
Sure. There is nothing wrong with writing an article " to compress the case for clojure for different people". We need those too.

When I read the title here on HN, I anticipated a balanced and comprehensive discussion on the design tradeoffs and was (mildly) disappointed to see that the article seemed to have a different focus (making a case for why Clojure is a language worth investing in, as far as I can make out).

I think Clojure is a brilliant language, but don't have enough experience with it to write about tradeoffs, and would really like to see a good discussion.

As I said in my original comment, it is a decent blog entry. My criticism is only about the (imo) mismatch between title and content.

Re:Clojure Tradeoffs by gtrak on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:14AM (#5944328)
FWIW, I agree, I would love to see an expert talk about real tradeoffs, both abstractly and in regards to clojure. I'm just kinda piecing it together from what I think Rich was thinking, what I've picked up from JoC, blogs, talks, and experience.
Re:Clojure Tradeoffs by brudgers on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:39AM (#5945596)
Don't beat yourself up over it too much. The structure of narrative form is something Clojure inherits from the Lisp tradition.

All essays about Clojure must either be a narrative in which "a man goes on a journey" or one in which "a stranger comes to town." [1] Yours, being the first type is just an old-fashioned love song to Lisp. [2] The other narrative form produces rants about s-expression syntax - though now that we have Python, praise of the semicolon is no longer a given.[3]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1213770

[2] e.g. RPG's www.dreamsongs.com

[3] Such essays, lacking condescension, may be said to fail to comprehend the essence of Lisp.